Gates vs Witten

[R0M0mentum09]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

LOL. Whatever you say.

It's unbelievable how BIASED these forums are. I honestly came in here unbiased and was slammed for doing so. . . not only did I state a case some people just completely ignored the point of this thread.

Everyone knows Gates is a dangerous receiving threat however Witten is far more consistent and his production is stellar. This isn't a debate on who the better highlight/TD player is . . .. it's who's the better OVERALL TE!

Which Witten is. . .

Gates is a Tier 8 Pass catcher
Witten is Tier 6

Gates is a Tier 4 blocker
Witten is a Tier 7

Making Witten The better OVERALL of the two. . . make sense?

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by R0M0mentum09

It's unbelievable how BIASED these forums are. I honestly came in here unbiased and was slammed for doing so. . . not only did I state a case some people just completely ignored the point of this thread. Everyone knows Gates is a dangerous receiving threat however Witten is far more consistent and his production is stellar. This isn't a debate on who the better highlight/TD player is . . .. it's who's the better OVERALL TE! Which Witten is. . . Gates is a Tier 8 Pass catcher Witten is Tier 6 Gates is a Tier 4 blocker Witten is a Tier 7 Making Witten The better OVERALL of the two. . . make sense?

Yeah you're unbiased.

[R0M0mentum09]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Yeah you're unbiased.

I am being unbiased in that statement. Gates is able to make plays catching the ball that Witten can't, however Witten CAN still catch the ball and make plays in the trenches Gates can't.

Don't be butthurt San Diego fan. . . I know your mad that your teams cursed :'(

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by R0M0mentum09

I am being unbiased in that statement. Gates is able to make plays catching the ball that Witten can't, however Witten CAN still catch the ball and make plays in the trenches Gates can't. Don't be butthurt San Diego fan. . . I know your mad that your teams cursed :'(

Ahh the old weak insult when someone doesn't agree with you. Straight out of Cowboy fan playbook. Well done.

Keep on being unbiased. LOL..

[R0M0mentum09]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Ahh the old weak insult when someone doesn't agree with you. Straight out of Cowboy fan playbook. Well done. Keep on being unbiased. LOL..

Sorry that wasn't an "insult" it was the truth. Your hate for "Cowboys fans" stems from your teams lack of historical success.

Gladly I will, I pride myself in being as unbiased as possible.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by R0M0mentum09

Sorry that wasn't an "insult" it was the truth. Your hate for "Cowboys fans" comes from your teams lack of historical success. Gladly I will, I pride myself in being as unbiased as possible.

Ahh another staple of the Cowboy fan playbook when they've got nothing.

[MadLivingLegend]

Simple Graded Math For You Guys.

Antonio Gates: Breakout Playmaker+Great Hands+Exceptional Route Runner= A

Jason Witten: Unbelievable Blocker+Great Line Adjuster+ HardNose Get Dirty Attitude= A

Comparing both of these players is like comparing oranges to apples! Both are great depending on the time of day! Let it rest. Equivalency is the proper term here!

[R0M0mentum09]

Quote: Originally Posted by MadLivingLegend

Simple Graded Math For You Guys. Antonio Gates: Breakout Playmaker+Great Hands+Exceptional Route Runner= A Jason Witten: Unbelievable Blocker+Great Line Adjuster+ HardNose Get Dirty Attitude= A Comparing both of these players is like comparing oranges to apples! Both are great depending on the time of day! Let it rest. Equivalency is the proper term here!

Exactly why I said 98 OVR for both.

Wittens hands are also underrated on Madden at a 90