Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

[R0M0mentum09]

Quote: Originally Posted by Stupendamatic

Please tell me you're not seriously asking me that question? To answer your question though, you base your opinion on what you see on the field not what you read on a stat sheet.

Yeah your exactly right, on the field I see Eli throwing 25 interceptions and costing his team ball games.

[vols bravesfan]

I know you won't take me seriously because I LOVE the Eagles but, Eli Manning is very overrated. Elite QB's don't throw 25 interceptions!

[RustyBlue]

To the guys that are saying Eli is overrated because of 25 INTs, they are wrong. If you watch the games, you would know that AT LEAST 6-7 of those interceptions were because of very catchable balls bouncing off of the receivers hands into the hands of the defenders.

oh yea and:

http://espn.go.com/blog/nfcwest/post...t-quarterbacks

[vols bravesfan]

He's not great though. 113 interceptions in six years is pretty bad if you ask me. Even Giants fans think he's terrible.

[DorneyDave86]

All the Cowboys should have 5 extra bonus points to their overall.

I have no reasoning behind this, I just am a Cowboys fan.

[Americas Team1]

Quote: Originally Posted by DorneyDave86

All the Cowboys should have 5 extra bonus points to their overall. I have no reasoning behind this, I just am a Cowboys fan.

Yeah well I say that every Cowboys player is over-rated.

I have no reasoning behind this, I just am a Cowboys h.a.t.e.r.

[RustyBlue]

Quote: Originally Posted by vols bravesfan

He's not great though. 113 interceptions in six years is pretty bad if you ask me. Even Giants fans think he's terrible.

He's better than matt schaub and tony romo imo

[vols bravesfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by Scooby803

He's better than matt schaub and tony romo imo

In some aspects, yes. Others, no. But that's football for you, everyone is good at something!