Anyone Else? Madden gone

[BlackJackRabbit]

I enjoyed the demo, and was excited for Madden, but I could only muster the motivation to play it for a solid week before my desire just disappeared. Madden 12 is better that Madden 11, clearly, but I'm seriously considering trading it in.

It's a better version of Madden 11, but the bulk of what Tiburon did with Madden was clean things up and put things back that were missing. There's really nothing new; it's the same game that plays a little differently. Next year I'm not paying attention to any articles touting improvements. I need to see a totally different game ( and game-play videos) with innovations for me to buy it.

[Steven123]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

I couldn't wait around for NCAA. I'm happy with my choice keeping Madden. Game play wise, best Madden I've played in a long time.

Unfortunately, being the "best" Madden as far as next-gen goes isnt saying much..

[Giants4Natic]

To me NCAA was horrible and I felt no connection to it this year. The gameplay felt like beta Madden 12

It was dull and boring and graphically was not as good even with the camera shots.

I traded it as soon as I could get $30 towards Madden.

Madden is far from a great game, but it is much better then NCAA 12 and a big jump from last year where it was the first time I ever traded madden in earlier then usual

I cannot stop playing madden 12 and doing sliders has been tons of fun.

Once I settle on sliders and the latest roster is out, I will start my NFL season

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by Steven123

Unfortunately, being the "best" Madden as far as next-gen goes isnt saying much..

That's ok, I skipped the PS1 and XBox era and played Madden on PC.

So, for me, on the field of play, I'm still justified in saying that it's the best playing Madden.

Each one of us is different.

[BlackJackRabbit]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

Maybe for you, that's ok, but I skipped the PS1 and XBox era and played Madden on PC. So, for me, on the field of play, I'm still justified in saying that it's the best playing Madden. Each one of us is different.

So basically, you have an ill-informed opinion.

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by BlackJackRabbit

So basically, you have an ill-informed opinion.

According to you, yes.

It's all it is, a personal opinion. Nothing more, nothing less.

You are right, everyone one else that likes 12 is wrong.

[BlackJackRabbit]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

According to you, yes. It's all it is, a personal opinion. Nothing more, nothing less. You are right, everyone one else that likes 12 is wrong.

You have an ill-informed opinion according to yourself .

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

That's ok, I skipped the PS1 and XBox era and played Madden on PC.

Otherwise, why mention this as an explanation of sorts as to why you think Madden 12 is the best Madden yet, which it is, and that being the best Madden yet is a valid complement in your eyes ?

Also, there's no need to patronize me.

[ABR173rd]

Quote: Originally Posted by BlackJackRabbit

You have an ill-informed opinion according to yourself . Otherwise, why mention this as an explanation of sorts as to why you think Madden 12 is the best Madden yet, which it is, and that being the best Madden yet is a valid complement in your eyes ? Also, there's no need to patronize me.

I'm pretty sure he's saying in comparison to previous versions of Madden in his eyes this is the best Madden- in COMPARISON to previous versions. Which isn't hard to agree with. On the flip side thats not saying Madden is where it should be or the best football game ever created......