They don't make the play in real life because a qb isn't throwing the ball right to them. Do you want EA to dumb the game down so you can throw over/by any defender without penalty? Go to rookie level and adjust the slider then...seriously I'm not saying anything about your skill level just if you want a game where you don't have to think or have any repercussions of your poor decisions then make it that way. But don't insist that EA make the game super simple and unrealistic to cover your on field inadequacies. That's the exact opposite of what the OS community is about.