Madden NFL 12 Ratings: Winners and Losers

[EHS_25]

Jordy Nelson is rated higher than Victor Cruz??? hmm... yeah i dont think so.

[raidertiger]

Quote: Originally Posted by camelworm

Mind you, this is coming from a 49er fan, but Andy Lee is definitely in the same league as Lechler. Both deserve to be in the high 90s. If I had to say one outperformed the other this year, it's Lee. Only punter with an average of 50 yards per punt this year, and he also got more inside the 20 than Lechler. What about Navorro Bowman & Ray McDonald on the 49ers? I can imagine that they must've been huge movers this season, and if they weren't, Madden wasn't paying attention. My copy of Madden is coming in the mail still, so I'll check then. I think Bowman is currently a high 80s overall? I assume he started lower than that. (And if I had my say, he would be in the 90s after outperforming Willis. I'd put McDonald in the high 80s at least as well).

Andy Lee is good, but a 97 is perfect for him. Lechler has a case for best P of all time.

[Champion8877]

if brady is a 99 then brees and rodgers should be atleast 100

[PGaither84]

What is with the obsession with OVR ratings? Seriously... they don't mean anything. Look at the individual ratings.

What is sad is that players abilities are often manipulated to alter their overall rather than giving them a true rating. It's sad really.

[bmj2k7]

Quote: Originally Posted by Champion8877

if brady is a 99 then brees and rodgers should be atleast 100

Well Brady is the only one left of those 3 QBs you just named and set a NFL record with 5 TDs in a half and tied the record for TDs in a game with 6!!! And honestly it could have been 8-10 if it wasn't for a early INT and fumble plus the just kept running the entire 2nd half bc the game was already over!!!! And if his DLine plays the way they did last week, and BAL average QB look worse than he is NE will be in the SB for Brady 5TH time, if I had to choose a playoff QB it would be Brady everytime. How is Greg Jennings not on the biggest losers bc he was just plain bad this year. Idk how Nelson is higher than 1500+ yards Cruz?

[Afrikan]

Quote: Originally Posted by adembroski

Andy Lee > Shane Lechler, he should be a 99

adem, have you spoke with Donnie about Dashon Goldson? I really believe he has been unfairly ignored the whole season. Sure he slowly got a few ratings bumps here and there, but he was started so low (don't know why) it didn't help much.

He has the size, the jumping ability, the awareness, the hit power, the speed.....and more importantly the stats, to prove where he belongs on the overall lists. He is starting in this year's Probowl...although he might not be able to play.

[seanyboy116]

ther is no arguin who the best punter in the nfl.... Shane Obviously

[JayTee86]

So Jared Allen hit 22 sacks this season and can't grab that 99?