Who was the best rated rookie ever?

Quote: Originally Posted by MattGarza13

If it was one of the pas 3 Maddens thats impossible. ^ Nobody comes out that high.

It is obviously not impossible is it? I had him, used him. Say what you want but I don't care what you think. I had him weather you believe me or not. I don't have to prove myself to you.

[TheDelta]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheSaints7

No, I did not import, he was called Wes Cameron. I do not even have NCCA, he was a 99 straight out the box. No kidding.

Sorry, but I have to call BS on this. There are only 30 classes of pregens and none of them have a QB above 80-ish OVR. There are no 99 OVR rookies in any pregen draft class.

[KBLover]

Quote: Originally Posted by PGaither84

When Willis was a rookie, it was Ray Lewis 2.0 on a defense that needed it. User Picks, tackles for a loss... hit stick! BOOM!

Willis still is Ray Lewis 2.0

Actually, he's probably better, especially in Madden. I've had both Ray and Willis and Willis is insane.

[PGaither84]

Quote: Originally Posted by KBLover

Willis still is Ray Lewis 2.0 Actually, he's probably better, especially in Madden. I've had both Ray and Willis and Willis is insane.

Well, yeah... but over time I now have enough faith in an AI controlled Willis to be a beast. I now control the ILB, which has been Spikes and now Bowman [and Bowman in my Madden 11 franchises.] Sure, I don't get as many user controlled Willis plays, but I get more consistent defense with Willis PLUS a user controlled LB than I would with user Willis and AI controlled ILB. To be fair, I take control of P Willy from time to time as well, but not that often. Most when he is about to make a play I switch over.

[KBLover]

Quote: Originally Posted by PGaither84

Well, yeah... but over time I now have enough faith in an AI controlled Willis to be a beast. I now control the ILB, which has been Spikes and now Bowman [and Bowman in my Madden 11 franchises.] Sure, I don't get as many user controlled Willis plays, but I get more consistent defense with Willis PLUS a user controlled LB than I would with user Willis and AI controlled ILB. To be fair, I take control of P Willy from time to time as well, but not that often. Most when he is about to make a play I switch over.

With the right sliders, CPU controlled Willis (I never control the ILBs for this reason, and rarely control the LBs - want to get the sliders to get the CPU to play the LBs correctly) is just as insane.

He's had as many as 16 tackles, INTs, sacks, all CPU controlled. Forced fumbles too. Heaven help the ball carriers if he's hot...

Quote: Originally Posted by TheDelta

Sorry, but I have to call BS on this. There are only 30 classes of pregens and none of them have a QB above 80-ish OVR. There are no 99 OVR rookies in any pregen draft class.

Believe what you want but I couldn't care what you think. I had him. I have no reason to lie about a poxy game.

[tflash81]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheSaints7

Believe what you want but I couldn't care what you think. I had him. I have no reason to lie about a poxy game.

Sorry sir but you are. There's a list of all the draft classes and I hate to tell you but there are no 99 rated rookies.

[zarmstead2]

I believe Suh was an 89