RG3 to be highest rated rookie in madden 13 and madden history?? with 88 or 89 rating

[LionsFanNJ]

Quote: Originally Posted by CRMosier_LM

Let's remember first off that overall rating means NOTHING outside of trade to/by cpu value. Absolutely nothing it has no effect in game. Highest rated ever was reggie bush I think at 86 overall. Do we really want them to not give a true representation of the players attributes just to lower the overall.rating? The guy will most likely have 94-98 speed AND acceleration based off of his on field play and history on the track (dam near world class sprinter). Based off of his last year in college his throwing power will be at least 88 and the only knock on his accuracy is the deep ball. Throwing on the run will probably be 85 plus but playaction will be low. Awareness should be no higher than 60 since he hasn't played in a pro style offense. Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk

This. RG III will probably come in with comparable rookie awr ratings and such, but the physical attributes will more than likely bump him up a few ovr points.

I bet if we plugged in Mike Vick rookie ratings in the current Madden ratings scheme he'd probably be similar. Sir Robert III probably has better passing ratings than Vick had at the same point so that may make him slightly higher.

Sent from my Ally using Tapatalk

[N51_rob]

He should be rated 99999999999.

[illwill10]

Quote: Originally Posted by CRMosier_LM

Let's remember first off that overall rating means NOTHING outside of trade to/by cpu value. Absolutely nothing it has no effect in game. Highest rated ever was reggie bush I think at 86 overall. Do we really want them to not give a true representation of the players attributes just to lower the overall.rating? The guy will most likely have 94-98 speed AND acceleration based off of his on field play and history on the track (dam near world class sprinter). Based off of his last year in college his throwing power will be at least 88 and the only knock on his accuracy is the deep ball. Throwing on the run will probably be 85 plus but playaction will be low. Awareness should be no higher than 60 since he hasn't played in a pro style offense. Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk

I agree with the Speed, ACC, and the THP. I think the THP will be at least 88 and at most 93.
But, most of the analysis on RG3 is that his touch on the deep ball and deep ball THA is good.

[Jarodd21]

Quote: Originally Posted by CRMosier_LM

Let's remember first off that overall rating means NOTHING outside of trade to/by cpu value. Absolutely nothing it has no effect in game. Highest rated ever was reggie bush I think at 86 overall. Do we really want them to not give a true representation of the players attributes just to lower the overall.rating? The guy will most likely have 94-98 speed AND acceleration based off of his on field play and history on the track (dam near world class sprinter). Based off of his last year in college his throwing power will be at least 88 and the only knock on his accuracy is the deep ball. Throwing on the run will probably be 85 plus but playaction will be low. Awareness should be no higher than 60 since he hasn't played in a pro style offense. Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk

You can't even knock that. His deep ball accuracy was one of the best ever in college history.. There is not many areas you can knock on RG3 besides not playing in a pro system and I'm sure that is the reason why his overall is going to be high because it's going to be hard for them to lower certain areas just to bring his overall down..

I have his throwing power being somewhere inbetween 92-94. There's no way it's going to be below 90..

[football5680]

No way. Luck will be rated higher so Griffin has no chance. He will be the #2 QB off the board and Luck is one of the most hyped QB's ever so he will easily beat griffin

[SteboSSK]

The whole idea of this is stupid. Its mainly for marketing. The man hasnt played a single down in the NFL but he is already gonna be rated higher than the majority of the QBs in the league outside the elite.

[N51_rob]

Quote: Originally Posted by football5680

No way. Luck will be rated higher so Griffin has no chance. He will be the #2 QB off the board and Luck is one of the most hyped QB's ever so he will easily beat griffin

Is this based on your opinion or knowledge of how madden ratings work? Casey is probably correct with his guesstamation.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus

[KBLover]

Quote: Originally Posted by LionsFanNJ

This. RG III will probably come in with comparable rookie awr ratings and such, but the physical attributes will more than likely bump him up a few ovr points.

I don't know - it's hard to imagine a QB making 89 OVR just on the strength of physical ratings.

Judging by the QBs in my franchise, I don't see many (any?) QBs that are 89-90 and have even questionable AWR or THA...

If he has a 60-ish AWR and iffy SAC/MAC, I think that knocks it down below 89-90.

Usually, players that far up have no real weaknesses at all. Is RG III THAT good?

Either that or he's going to have 99 SPD - probably rating him like he's Desean Jackson SPD/ACC-wise (100/90-something)?