Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

[jmurphy31]

Quote: Originally Posted by CHooe

Clarification: you can still make that roster, you just can only use it in Play Now games.

I understood that part. But playing a bunch of play now games is not my idea of fun.

[DeuceDouglas]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bearsfan1

I think Madden Developers will quickly realize that they made a pretty huge mistake with this. Franchise mode no longer has replay ability because of it. EA will probably put it back in for M14 but use it as a "New Feature" like they think we're a bunch of idiots. "This year we're bringing you total control with your team's players and roster in connected careers!" ...

I can see it now. June 4th, 2013. Los Angeles, California. E3. Cam Weber standing on stage and then in the background a video begins playing of Ray Lewis doing the same speech as this year, but with all sorts of equipment changing on him. Then quickly fade into the player edit screen for a killer player edit montage. [/sarcasm]

In all seriousness, I wasn't expecting us to not be able to edit rosters in any way whatsoever. That is pretty disappointing seeing as how by the time the game comes out final rosters will almost be set.

[SteelerSpartan]

Quote: Originally Posted by DeuceDouglas

I can see it now. June 4th, 2013. Los Angeles, California. E3. Cam Weber standing on stage and then in the background a video begins playing of Ray Lewis doing the same speech as this year, but with all sorts of equipment changing on him. Then quickly fade into the player edit screen for a killer player edit montage. [/sarcasm] In all seriousness, I wasn't expecting us to not be able to edit rosters in any way whatsoever. That is pretty disappointing seeing as how by the time the game comes out final rosters will almost be set.

Nothing would surprise me at this point.....I was getting good and pumped about the game but now Im not only worried about this years title but also how this stuff is going to affect games beyond that

[DukeC]

My expression is this right now after reading this:

They screwed over everyone who doesn't have access to Xbox Live. I hope they realize this.

At least before guys (or gals) had the option to go in and manually edit the players who became breakout stars or edit someone who was having a crappy year.

Now, they are COMPLETELY STUCK WITH THE DEFAULT ROSTERS IN THE GAME. You guys can't even use the USB thing now, because you still can't take those rosters into CC.

Jesus I didn't think the oversight was this bad until now.

Wow EA. Just wow. This was a really bad move. A REALLY REALLY BAD MOVE.

[DCEBB2001]

LOL! I cannot help but laugh at this. Once again EA shows how horrible they manage stuff. You can't use edited rosters in CC? Unreal! Well looks like 5 years (and going strong) of NOT buying Madden again. Even worse for me, is that nobody can enjoy FBGratings in CC mode.

Great job EA!

[billsmafia13]

Quote: Originally Posted by drlw322

I guess a work around would be to retire as the coach and pick each player you want to edit and play as them and edit them and retire and go back to being he head coach. Assume that is possible

I don't know that you can even edit your "superstar" player after you start CC. I'm almost 100% positive you cannot.

[Tweeg]

Quote: Originally Posted by Gotmadskillzson

Only way they can fix this problem for Madden 13 is for Donny Moore to completely change his philosophy when it comes to ratings. Such as the following: USE THE ENTIRE 0 to 99 scale. Stop giving so many players 90 plus speed. Stop giving so many defenders play recognition, pursuit, hit power, tackling, block shedding ratings from 88 to 95. Stop giving everybody high acceleration and agility ratings in the high 80s to mid 90s. Stop giving players that weight 280 pounds and above 88 speed. Stop giving 190 pound players 83 strength. Stop giving so many players a jump rating in the 90s. So I hope they use common sense this year when they rate the players, since it is their way or the high way. When you have so many players with over the top high ratings, it breaks the game. There is no organic flow to it if everybody have high acceleration, high speed, high agility. Every defender got the tackling ability of Dick Butkus. Every defensive back got the recovery speed of Deon Sanders. Truly SPREAD OUT THE RATINGS. Use the entire 0 to 99 scale. Stop going from 60 to 99 only.

This + 1,000. An overall rating of 75 should be viewed as a good player. Currently guys in that rating range are third string.

[Jarodd21]

Play now huh? What sense does that make? Who wants to edit rosters to use in Play now. The whole point is to fix the rosters and take it to your franchise..