Possible depth chart issue

[ghettoqball]

Honestly, is anyone surprised by this?

[mojo6911]

Quote: Originally Posted by ManiacMatt1782

Should a Tackle take a 7-8 point ratings jut for playing the opposite side. I could see a 3 point hit, not 8.

Yes, possibly more. Right Tackle and Left Tackle are quite a bit different, and in most blocking schemes, requires a much different skill set.

[boritter]

Quote: Originally Posted by debauchlord

Even at 84, though, is he better than the incumbent RT? Also, you are looking at another team's roster through YOUR team's particular set up (west coast, hybrid, etc.) Someone needs to CCM Carolina and see what their set up is and how it rates Grant.

Regardless of the system Grant should never be better than Williams. This just seems like an elaborate way for the CPU to have 2nd & 3rd stringers start. CCM is great in theory but lacks practicality.

[billsmafia13]

Seems like a really big issue. Why is this not gaining more traction?

If FAs always start, what the heck happens after an offseason??

[payton425]

hopefully in patch....is this tied to coaching schemes? don't the ea game changers suppose to be looking for this stuff? step your game up boys!! lol...

[ManiacMatt1782]

Quote: Originally Posted by mojo6911

Yes, possibly more. Right Tackle and Left Tackle are quite a bit different, and in most blocking schemes, requires a much different skill set.

what about flipping for an opposite handed qb. A left tackle for a right handed qb, should be very similar to a right tackle for a left handed qb. If your back up qb is opposite handed, you may need scheme wise to flip your tackles.

[davo1021]

Quote: Originally Posted by debauchlord

Even at 84, though, is he better than the incumbent RT? Also, you are looking at another team's roster through YOUR team's particular set up (west coast, hybrid, etc.) Someone needs to CCM Carolina and see what their set up is and how it rates Grant.

I did this earlier today for another thread. If you use a power running back (which is what Carolina is set to) then Grant is an 86 overall, Stewart is an 81, and Williams drops to a 71. This part is not a bug, Grant just fits better for Carolina's scheme than Williams does.


But the right/left switching is something I have noticed although it has not dropped my players overall at all

[davo1021]

Quote: Originally Posted by billsmafia13

Seems like a really big issue. Why is this not gaining more traction? If FAs always start, what the heck happens after an offseason??

FAs don't always start. Don't worry. In the case of Ryan Grant starting over DeAngelo Williams is because the Panthers use a power run HB which makes Grant much better in overall than Williams