We got Ratings issues..not cool..

[beauforsure]

I just did a test run on NCAA 14 , Ratings do not matter. This means same for Madden

I put in a OVR 40 WR with a 39 THP 18 ACC that completed passes and i saw no differnce in ACC or THP considering hes rated so low , and i threw in a OVR 40 MLB at HB and he was making cuts like a normal HB. lol.. its so stupid i was laughing.. So basically i can throw in anyone i want and there is hardly no difference of player rating no matter how highly rated.

Even the speed seems similar but that might be the only rating that is accounted for cuz sum players are faster it seems.

This is not good tho. for those people who think getting high rated players makes a diff. well i guess not.

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by beauforsure

I just did a test run on NCAA 14 , Ratings do not matter. This means same for Madden I put in a OVR 40 WR with a 39 THP 18 ACC that completed passes and i saw no differnce in ACC or THP considering hes rated so low , and i threw in a OVR 40 MLB at HB and he was making cuts like a normal HB. lol.. its so stupid i was laughing.. So basically i can throw in anyone i want and there is hardly no difference of player rating no matter how highly rated. Even the speed seems similar but that might be the only rating that is accounted for cuz sum players are faster it seems. This is not good tho. for those people who think getting high rated players makes a diff. well i guess not.

Interesting find.

I had Rodgers injuried and Graham Harrell came in, the back up QB.

Harrell was 1 of 7 with 2 int's. He couldn't hit the braodside of a barn on my settings.

[psychraider32]

One game is a poor sample size. Trust me, try playing with Blaine Gabbert or Chad Henne as your quarterbacks. Ratings matter.

[Cavicchi]

Do ratings matter for your offensive line?

[Cre8]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

Interesting find. I had Rodgers injuried and Graham Harrell came in, the back up QB. Harrell was 1 of 7 with 2 int's. He couldn't hit the braodside of a barn on my settings.

I had ARod get hurt but had the opposite with Harrell... 6/7 for 102 yards and a TD drive to win the game (Default All-Madden).

*Did you tweak the sliders at all? outside of default difficulty?*

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cre8

I had ARod get hurt but had the opposite with Harrell... 6/7 for 102 yards and a TD drive to win the game (Default All-Madden). *Did you tweak the sliders at all? outside of default difficulty?*

Oh yeah, custom, QBA at 15, Pblkg at 25, Pass Coverage and Reaction at 60.

[ggsimmonds]

Seems like we go through this every year.
The ratings matter, the issue is the scale. A guy rated 40 for every thing will perform better than one would think because the rating "floor" is not that low.

If you want to prove your point, you will need more than "39 THP 18 ACC that completed passes and i saw no differnce in ACC or THP"

[FreAk47]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cre8

I had ARod get hurt but had the opposite with Harrell... 6/7 for 102 yards and a TD drive to win the game (Default All-Madden). *Did you tweak the sliders at all? outside of default difficulty?*

I had this happen as well, Rodgers breaks his collarbone on the 2nd play...Harrell comes in and goes 9-10 for 120 yards and 1 TD. The only incompletion was actually a catch but since the challenge system is still borked...I couldn't challenge it. All throws were right on the money, really saw no difference in the 2. Default All-Madden.