Just a thought.

[K33057]

Been thinking that I wish this site would have a section for just Classic Teams/Rosters and we could vote? on each player for each position and then talk about what rating each player would get.. There are Lots of people who Love old time players. Just a section for the classic rosters..?
Just a thought..

[sandfoot]

Re: Just a thought.

Good idea. I'm always messing with classic rosters. Most my problems come with player ratings. Moose has a spreadsheet for offense that works good. I wonder if anyone has a spreadsheet for defense? If so feel free to post it here.

[mathteachernerd1968]

Re: Just a thought.

Sounds good to me!

Maybe we just need one thread here, PS3/360 for classic rosters. Keep bumping it. Put all downloads on the thread in the 1st post....

I don't even play Madden, NBA2K, or MLB The Game without classic all-franchise rosters. I figure I can include lots of current players if they're good enough to make the roster.

[K33057]

Re: Just a thought.

Im really shocked this has not taken off..
Ok, I figure 4 players for each position.. let's say Steeler HB's Harris-Bettis-Foster-Parker?.. and then rate them. This way those who want to make Great Teams wont have to do HOURS of research, unless they dont agree with the players picked.. I mean LOOK at how many times when each madden comes out one of the 1st questions asked is " what about Classic teams, or is there All-time teams..
If there was a section for that , it would make it alot easier..
I think Every sport here should have a classic section.