Now my biggest problem with 08 and 09 on 360 is the fact that manual catching is now done with holding Y. Not timing it like it was done on ps2 which had the most fluid gameplay and stick skills because of it, but instead with no skill holding down the Y button. This has caused problems on both sides of the ball -- offense and defense with this system in place because at times even defenders won't jump like they use to on ps2 when you're in position and tap the Y button at the right time.
So my request is, if you guys leave down the holding Y button for manual catch, why not just make it all timing ala PS2 on the All-Madden skill set only? I figure it's an easy solution and great idea if the holding Y terribleness is still in Madden 10. This way, guys who aren't as skilled or with good reaction time can still hold Y down and get animations...but not on All-Madden. This would keep the hardcore gamers and top guys like myself happy because while we play on All-Madden the great fluidty of PS2 days control would be back where it took skill to pull off these kind of catches with consistency and again, fluity. Just an idea I thought I'd throw out there! Looking forward to Madden 10 and hoping it's a great one like the ps2 glory days!
Comment