good trade

[sportsdude2009]

I have madden 2009 for the ps2 i'm the giants and Eli Manning for some reason can only get 1 touch down a game and no one catches it however with David Carr he can get more than 1 touchdown and people catch it so I traded Eli to the Broncoes for Joey Harrington is this a good move and if not what should i have done?

[Scott]

Re: good trade

Eli>Harrington

[MattUMD224]

Re: good trade

I have madden 2009 for the ps2 i'm the giants and Eli Manning for some reason can only get 1 touch down a game and no one catches it however with David Carr he can get more than 1 touchdown and people catch it so I traded Eli to the Broncoes for Joey Harrington is this a good move and if not what should i have done?

joey harrington for eli manning is the dumbest thing in the world....One touchdown a game is normal bud....but its your game you should trade eli manning to a team that needs a quarterback and get a 1st and 2nd or 3rd round pick for him

[sportsdude2009]

Re: good trade

joey harrington for eli manning is the dumbest thing in the world....One touchdown a game is normal bud....but its your game you should trade eli manning to a team that needs a quarterback and get a 1st and 2nd or 3rd round pick for him

maybe it is the dumbest thing to do and yeah it is normal to score one touchdown but to have your team lose like 56 to 14 that's not good and with carr i scored more than one touchdown and people actually caught the ball when I threw it to them

[MattIntellect]

Re: good trade

maybe it is the dumbest thing to do and yeah it is normal to score one touchdown but to have your team lose like 56 to 14 that's not good and with carr i scored more than one touchdown and people actually caught the ball when I threw it to them

Maybe, it's a problem with the video game because I can assure you that everyone will agree that Eli Manning is WAY better than Joey Harrington in real-life. You can NEVER expect a trade like that!

[sportsdude2009]

Re: good trade

Maybe, it's a problem with the video game because I can assure you that everyone will agree that Eli Manning is WAY better than Joey Harrington in real-life. You can NEVER expect a trade like that!

well i'm about to find out because i'm about to play madden

[MattIntellect]

Re: good trade

well i'm about to find out because i'm about to play madden

Madden is the only place for a trade like that. Wait, actually Eli Manning is rated higher than Joey Harrington, especially considering that the Giants won the superbowl.

[tmccormi]

Re: good trade

Maybe, it's a problem with the video game because I can assure you that everyone will agree that Eli Manning is WAY better than Joey Harrington in real-life. You can NEVER expect a trade like that!

I would hand over my Giants-fan card the day the Giants ever did something like this...

[sportsdude2009]

Re: good trade

you guys are right this is the stupidest decision ever i was facing broncoes in preseason kind of ironic isn't it anyway harrington in the second half was only 4 for 18 with 2 interceptions and no touchdowns and i lost i was winning in the first half then after the second i started to loose it but i think i just need to practice with harrington

[PantherBeast_OS]

Re: good trade

LOL bro Eli is way better then harrington. That sounds like a bad trade to me. Should of aleast traded him for a guy just *** good as him.

[CKW11]

Re: good trade

If you did that trade you should be fired as GM.

[sportsdude2009]

Re: good trade

well all i had to do was to practice but he's better in the game now

[MRxAmazing]

Re: good trade

I don't know what to make of this thread. It's horrific though.

[sportsdude2009]

Re: good trade

the thread,trade,or both

[MattIntellect]

Re: good trade

the thread,trade,or both

Both.

This is the craziest trade/thread IMO.

There is no debate as to whether or not Eli should be traded for Joey Harrington!