Even CPU-controlled greats like Brady and Roethlisberger, when they manage to move the ball down the field, will turn into Joey Harrington's inside the Red Zone, making poor reads, often throwing into double and triple coverages, leading to many pick 6's.
Seems like the awareness rating doesn't equal intelligence which means major disappointment for those of us wanting NFL sim experiences offline. The only way to have any shot at a close game is for me to use the house rules NOT to audible or hot route, to stay away from slants, and to NOT play as a defensive lineman. That is the only way the CPU has a chance to score and then it turns into a track meet / shootout.
Not to mention all the other idiot moves the CPU coach pulls such as attempting a field goal from the 37 yard line when down by 4 late in the 4th quarter, running (using a non-run-heavy team) on critical 3rd and longs, leaving my top WR uncovered by not lining anyone up against him, blitzing far too often, terrible pursuit angles, running out of bounds when wide open, etc.
Can EA implement an intelligence slider? I agree with versus2 that everything you see on Sunday is in this game, EXCEPT coaching.