Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ab2c4
    Pro
    • Jul 2004
    • 788

    #1

    Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

    I'm done with "next gen" Madden for awhile and want to go back to the glory years on the ps2. Which would you recommend as the best Madden out of these three years? I figured I won't be taking too much of a risk since all of these versions will only cost around $1.

    Or is another year better? I did play Madden 09 on the ps2 and wasn't too crazy about it so I am thinking one of these other older versions might be more fun to me.
  • hatisback
    Banned
    • Nov 2004
    • 1013

    #2
    Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

    Madden 2005 FTW. That, along with the Manifesto by SM27 provide a full sim experience. If you want, check out my Brown's franchise I just started using Madden 2005. After picking this up, I haven't looked back. Yea, that good.

    Comment

    • ab2c4
      Pro
      • Jul 2004
      • 788

      #3
      Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

      Originally posted by hatisback
      Madden 2005 FTW. That, along with the Manifesto by SM27 provide a full sim experience. If you want, check out my Brown's franchise I just started using Madden 2005. After picking this up, I haven't looked back. Yea, that good.
      Manifesto by SM27? Please explain.

      Comment

      • splff3000
        MVP
        • Jun 2003
        • 2867

        #4
        Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

        Hey man, I would seriously look at 07. I know it wasn't on your list, but I think 07 was the best madden on last gen, especially for franchise. Madden 08 was just a rehash of 07 and I never played 09 so I can't tell you about that.
        PSN - Splff3000
        Twitch

        Comment

        • ab2c4
          Pro
          • Jul 2004
          • 788

          #5
          Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

          When you guys talk about Franchise, do you play your games or do you sim them?

          Comment

          • DJ
            Hall Of Fame
            • Apr 2003
            • 17756

            #6
            Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

            I'd give Madden 09 another shot. I have that game and really enjoy it.

            As for the older titles, 06 is a lot of fun. I was anti Vision Cone at first but now I really like the feature. 05 is great if you like to play defense; I think it's the toughest Madden out there in terms of difficulty.

            You could just pick up 04, 05 and 06 and try them out for a week and then return the 1 or 2 that you don't like as much as the other, since you can return used games within 7 days at GameStop.
            Currently Playing:
            MLB The Show 25 (PS5)

            Comment

            • pw_1016
              Pro
              • Nov 2009
              • 770

              #7
              Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

              I would say, first, that you should give 09 another shot. What did you not like about it? I love the super sim feature, plus it has the feature from years past (07 i think) were you can change into a blocker on a run play so that the RB breaks for more yardage.

              Comment

              • joejccva71
                Banned
                • Mar 2008
                • 1535

                #8
                Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

                As far as older gen Maddens like Madden 05, a few questions:

                1. Can I play it on my xbox360?

                2. Is there a site where I can download the LATEST rosters for it, kinda like what 2k5rosters did?

                Comment

                • o Mass Murda o
                  Banned
                  • Aug 2008
                  • 431

                  #9
                  Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

                  i'd have to give the nod to madden 07 as well. man i put so many hours into that game. thats when i used to easily get in 400+ online games and was my main game on ps2. the last old gen madden b4 i jumped up to xbox360. now i have 1 ranked gm on madden 10(i do play all offline franch tho), skipped 09, about 50 in madden 08. that there should tell u the quality compared with next gen's

                  some '07 highlights:

                  -double juke/cut moves
                  -be the lead blocker
                  -playmaker controls
                  -good graphics (for the time)
                  -good franchise
                  -vision cone is there, just optional if u wanted to use it
                  -ran buttery smooth and had good animations
                  -fun rushing attack mini game (had 400+ online gms of this too, use to warm up with it b4 i would play online ranked gms)

                  Comment

                  • jWILL253
                    You know why I'm here...
                    • Jun 2008
                    • 1611

                    #10
                    Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

                    Madden 07, 08 if you want Hit Stick 2.0. Still playing 07 to this day...
                    jWILL

                    Comment

                    • 24
                      Forever A Legend
                      • Sep 2008
                      • 2809

                      #11
                      Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

                      can't go wrong with 05


                      Comment

                      • lofeazy
                        Banned
                        • Jan 2010
                        • 586

                        #12
                        Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

                        Can you still play online for 07 are anything older?

                        Comment

                        • Tick32
                          Banned
                          • Sep 2009
                          • 276

                          #13
                          Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

                          They were the best ones IMO. but Madden 10 ps2 shouldnt be any diff. Didnt look diff to me when i watched a vid on it. had bettter features than 360/ps3 version

                          Comment

                          • Bgamer90
                            MVP
                            • Jul 2008
                            • 1919

                            #14
                            Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

                            Madden 04 is HIGHLY overrated imo. Overpowering offense, a lot of suction, sloppy menu/interface system, etc.

                            It was enjoyable & good during it's time but unless you are really into franchise mode features, I can't see how one could like 04 more than 10.

                            But anyways, my favorite last gen Madden is 05, though I still like 10 better mainly due to how much suction there was in the last gen games.
                            Bgamer90 on twitter

                            Comment

                            • joejccva71
                              Banned
                              • Mar 2008
                              • 1535

                              #15
                              Re: Looking to pick up Madden on the ps2: 04, 05, or 06?

                              Is there a site to get the latest roster updates for Madden 05 or 07 that people may have done themselves and released? Kinda like nfl2k5rosters.com site?

                              Comment

                              Working...