Should madden add draft class creator?

[beastsofboston]

I like the idea. It can be in team builder form where you go online to create the class. But i would like it so you can edit the rookies ratings and those will be the final ratings in the class.

I personaly hate the ncaa import system, because its so hard to get a realistic draft class.

But we could have an ea locker or something like that to share and edit each others draft class.

[thesublime]

NBA 2k10 did this...worked pretty well. The only point of contention is that you will already know the highly rated/high potential guys if you're the original creator. Of course, it would REALLY be a great tool add rookies after the draft...which is why it won't happen. NBA 2k10 got away with it because they had no CBB game to sync with. EA won't let us have the upper hand...ever. A feature like this would essentially allow roster creators to carry on with one installment of Madden for years.

[beastsofboston]

Quote: Originally Posted by thesublime

NBA 2k10 did this...worked pretty well. The only point of contention is that you will already know the highly rated/high potential guys if you're the original creator. Of course, it would REALLY be a great tool add rookies after the draft...which is why it won't happen. NBA 2k10 got away with it because they had no CBB game to sync with. EA won't let us have the upper hand...ever. A feature like this would essentially allow roster creators to carry on with one installment of Madden for years.

exactually what i was thinking. It is not likely because of ncaa. And ya thats what i was thinking about 2k10, i own that game as well and think the draft class creator is a great idea and works well.

[Exonerated]

Re: Should madden add draft class creator?

No, because less people will buy NCAA 11. [Reasonable conclusion]

Should there be a draft class creator?

I'd love one.

[Boregard]

Quote: Originally Posted by Exonerated

Re: Should madden add draft class creator? No, because less people will buy NCAA 11. [Reasonable conclusion] Should there be a draft class creator? I'd love one.

Should they = yes
Will they = no

At the very least they should allow us to fully edit the crap they put in the game as "Madden generated classes"!!!

[rooney8]

Quote: Originally Posted by Exonerated

Re: Should madden add draft class creator? No, because less people will buy NCAA 11. [Reasonable conclusion] Should there be a draft class creator? I'd love one.

You said it man.
Only thing that can happen is they make importing better. Really not that hard as you don't need to randomise it every time and just make it Ncaa good player= Madden good player. Hope they followed there simpler theme with importing this year.

[lordnate]

I'm not in favor of it, because you will obviously know what the players in the draft are rated. Try this idea.

Draft class sliders. You could edit nearly every aspect of the draft statistically. You think RBs in the draft aren't good enough, turn up the RB slider. You think the WRs are too good, turn down the slider. Not enough OLBs are 34 rush OLBs, turn up the pass rush priority for OLBs. This would even be better if implemented with progression sliders.

If EA can't fix the game, they should give us the ability to do it. Further, no game will please everyone. But if the game is customizable, everyone can find a setting they like.

[rooney8]

You can't add sliders for everything in games. I don't have a problem with having a good idea of how good players are in the draft. Do you think the Lions had no clue how good Suh is when they drafted him?