NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • nasatate
    Rookie
    • Oct 2008
    • 76

    #1

    NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

    Played a conference championship game against the Saints. I was so excited it reached overtime and the commentators were talking about it and on the screen as well it explains the new rule changes. Played the OT, Saints got the ball first, drove all the way to the 30, kicked a field goal and GAME OVER. WTF???
  • tktnuri
    Rookie
    • Oct 2007
    • 216

    #2
    Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

    lol.. totally forgot about the this rule change. Isn't there a salary cap as well for the 2010 season?

    Comment

    • JWurm7
      Rookie
      • Aug 2010
      • 37

      #3
      Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

      Wow... haven't had the situation occur, but if that's true they gotta fix that. I mean that's really bad since they actually go out of their way to mention the OT change.

      Comment

      • JoeSchroeduh
        Rookie
        • Aug 2009
        • 45

        #4
        Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

        Happened to me... they kicked the FG and Gus Johnson screamed COLTS WIN... and then they had to kick off to me after and I drove for a TD and the win.

        Comment

        • nastynacho1
          Banned
          • Nov 2008
          • 156

          #5
          Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

          Originally posted by tktnuri
          lol.. totally forgot about the this rule change. Isn't there a salary cap as well for the 2010 season?
          There's always a salary cap

          Comment

          • canes21
            Hall Of Fame
            • Sep 2008
            • 22906

            #6
            Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

            In real life there isn't, but I left it on to keep single player challenging since this isn't my money and I wouldn't care to dish out 100 million per player.
            “No one is more hated than he who speaks the truth.”


            ― Plato

            Comment

            • nasatate
              Rookie
              • Oct 2008
              • 76

              #7
              Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

              Originally posted by JoeSchroeduh
              Happened to me... they kicked the FG and Gus Johnson screamed COLTS WIN... and then they had to kick off to me after and I drove for a TD and the win.
              weird cuz i didnt get the chance to get the ball at all. the game just ended.

              Comment

              • PGaither84
                MVP
                • Mar 2009
                • 4393

                #8
                Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

                Originally posted by nastynacho1
                There's always a salary cap
                Not this year there wasn't.
                My Madden Blog

                Comment

                • RayAllen20
                  MVP
                  • Jun 2009
                  • 1825

                  #9
                  Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

                  Originally posted by nasatate
                  Played a conference championship game against the Saints. I was so excited it reached overtime and the commentators were talking about it and on the screen as well it explains the new rule changes. Played the OT, Saints got the ball first, drove all the way to the 30, kicked a field goal and GAME OVER. WTF???
                  I dont think the OT rules apply to the playoffs...
                  I will always, always be a Jets fan. But trust me it hurts.

                  Comment

                  • PGaither84
                    MVP
                    • Mar 2009
                    • 4393

                    #10
                    Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

                    Originally posted by RayAllen20
                    I dont think the OT rules apply to the playoffs...
                    you have it backwards
                    My Madden Blog

                    Comment

                    • FedExPope
                      Pro
                      • Aug 2009
                      • 900

                      #11
                      Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

                      This is just ridiculous. One guy gets the ball after the field goal (after Gus declares a winner) and another has the game end after a field goal.

                      What the hell? How does something like this break? Who is coding over there at Tiburon?

                      Comment

                      • havokeff
                        Rookie
                        • Dec 2009
                        • 308

                        #12
                        Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

                        I was just about to post a thread about this and the search function (very nice by the way) showed a couple similar threads, so sorry for the necro, but I was pretty annoyed.

                        I got the JIM Harbaugh led Niners to the Superbowl in the third year of a franchise I was actually playing quite a few of the games in, so I had some actual vested interest in the team I built. And of course as luck would have it, my opposition is the JOHN Harbaugh led Ravens, so I just had to play this game.

                        I also wanted to test out a new slider/speed setup and figured this would be the perfect game to do it in.

                        Back and fourth game. Long runs, surprisingly long passes. Score for score and the Ravens kick a 48 yard field goal that bounces in off the bottom cross bar of the goal post with 30 seconds to go in regulation to tie. That kinda game.

                        So I get into overtime totally stoked at how good the slider/speed set played.

                        Ravens win the toss. Receive. First play from scrimmage, I blitz into a Fing draw to Ricky Williams (surprised he hadn't retired yet) who runs 80 F-ing yards for a TD! HOLDING! HAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Suck it Mr. Blindside!

                        The Ravens then proceed to march on me to the 30, where I stuff them on 3 consecutive running plays and Patrick Willis gets some revenge on Williams by sending him off on the cart.

                        48 yard field goal attempt. Bounces in off the upright! ARE YOU KIDDING ME!

                        Ok well at least with the new overtime rul- WHAT THE F**K IS WITH THE CONFETTI!!

                        I'll say it again, I am annoyed.

                        These are the things that make me want to punch the developers. Not the things that don't exist like physic DBs and LBs, or the occasional stat anomaly.

                        Something like this should be found in the testing phase shouldn't it? I mean, I can't imagine that Madden could possibly short of testers that would probably work for free. No one thought to check to make sure one of the most controversial rule changes in quite a while actually worked?

                        Now, of course reading through the thread, I noticed that on one occasion the ending was triggered, but the game kept going, and on other times it didn't. I am wondering if because of the TD that was called back, that the CPU only registered it as a score and disregarded that it was called back and that that somehow that made it go into sudden death mode. I'm thinking that since the score didn't trigger the ending, it chalked it up as a field goal and that the CPU doesn't differentiate between WHO scored, just that there was a score and now it is sudden death.

                        That I could forgive as a bug that would be hard to catch. If not though...
                        Punch right in the face EA.

                        Comment

                        • kpkpkp
                          Banned
                          • Mar 2007
                          • 1733

                          #13
                          Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

                          Originally posted by havokeff
                          I was just about to post a thread about this and the search function (very nice by the way) showed a couple similar threads, so sorry for the necro, but I was pretty annoyed.

                          ....

                          Ravens win the toss. Receive. First play from scrimmage, I blitz into a Fing draw to Ricky Williams (surprised he hadn't retired yet) who runs 80 F-ing yards for a TD! HOLDING! HAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Suck it Mr. Blindside!

                          The Ravens then proceed to march on me to the 30, where I stuff them on 3 consecutive running plays and Patrick Willis gets some revenge on Williams by sending him off on the cart.

                          48 yard field goal attempt. Bounces in off the upright! ARE YOU KIDDING ME!

                          Ok well at least with the new overtime rul- WHAT THE F**K IS WITH THE CONFETTI!!

                          I'll say it again, I am annoyed.

                          ....


                          Now, of course reading through the thread, I noticed that on one occasion the ending was triggered, but the game kept going, and on other times it didn't. I am wondering if because of the TD that was called back, that the CPU only registered it as a score and disregarded that it was called back and that that somehow that made it go into sudden death mode. I'm thinking that since the score didn't trigger the ending, it chalked it up as a field goal and that the CPU doesn't differentiate between WHO scored, just that there was a score and now it is sudden death.

                          That I could forgive as a bug that would be hard to catch. If not though...
                          Punch right in the face EA.
                          I was playing a game in exhibition mode. (which does include the new OT rules for playoffs.)

                          Anyways, Im the Pats playing Buffalo, and the game goes to OT.

                          The Bills get the coin toss, and get close enough to succesfully kick a FG. Im of course thinking... "OK I get the ball back."

                          Suddenly the confetti starts flying with the Bills are jumping around and Im like "What the heck?"... Just as soon as Im ready to rant about the game being bugged the Bills are suddenly back on the field kicking to me.

                          Low and behold I get a TD... and the confetti starts flying again only this time my guys are jumping around...

                          Aaanyway long story short something is definetly bugged here. In my story there was no scoring that was brought back by a penalty.. so maybe thats why my outcome was different. But something is bugged.

                          It's been this way for 2 years as you can tell when you went "necro" and brought back a year old thread.

                          I doubt they'll fix if they even know its bugged.
                          Last edited by kpkpkp; 10-04-2011, 09:48 AM.

                          Comment

                          • BlackJackRabbit
                            Rookie
                            • Aug 2011
                            • 184

                            #14
                            Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

                            "True to the Game."

                            This is why there's so much angst towards EA. They don't care about the product that they put out.

                            There is nothing that any apologist can say to excuse the fact that the overtime rules don't apply in Madden.

                            Comment

                            • Slayer82186
                              Rookie
                              • Jul 2011
                              • 109

                              #15
                              Re: NEW OVERTIME RULE DOESNT WORK

                              Originally posted by PGaither84
                              Not this year there wasn't.
                              No last year there was no salary cap. This year there is one.

                              Comment

                              Working...