Challenges

[Bill1]

This is not a bug. but anyone Challenge and it look sure enough that you will win, and then they said play stands as call. I just started a Game vs Saints, and there WR caught the ball and had 1 foot out of bound, he ran it into the endzone for a TD. i Challenge and played call as stands.

[Drtro]

Re: Challenges

Ever since they started using 3D grass, those kind of plays have been happening all of the time.

[whodey85]

Re: Challenges

These type of plays happen all the time in real life... Ok.. maybe not all the time but definitely do happen. As odd as it sounds, it being imperfect is actually realistic in my opinion.

[vicaddict]

Re: Challenges

Actually I believe that challenges are broken. It's like 90% of the time that I waste a time out, because they rule in favour of the CPU. It's somewhat silly. Sometimes you can't even challenge, even if it says to press L2 on the PS3.

[dcmantommy72]

Re: Challenges

imo challenges are certainly not where they need to be.

Sure blown calls after a review happen.. but not that much..

In my experience I tend to win mine more often than not, just hope the system improves for next year.

[tentionfree]

Re: Challenges

Dear i think actually I believe that challenges are broken. It's like 90% of the time that I waste a time out, because they rule in favour of the CPU. It's somewhat silly. Sometimes you can't even challenge, even if it says to press L2 on the PS3...!!!

[Zodiac25]

Re: Challenges

Dear i think actually I believe that challenges are broken. It's like 90% of the time that I waste a time out, because they rule in favour of the CPU. It's somewhat silly. Sometimes you can't even challenge, even if it says to press L2 on the PS3...!!!

I have found when it says press L2 to challenge and you can't, it's after a turnover, so it's automatically reviewed as in real life

[KBLover]

Re: Challenges

These type of plays happen all the time in real life... Ok.. maybe not all the time but definitely do happen. As odd as it sounds, it being imperfect is actually realistic in my opinion.

I just wish it was as inaccurate for the CPU.

I challenge a sideline catch - play stands almost always. CPU challenges a sideline catch - it's reversed almost always.

If both sides could screw up a challenge, fine - then it's like real life. But for the CPU to challenge only when it's "certain" it will be overturned and me being hit or miss - that's not like real life.

Only times it gets iffy is on booth reviews - those seem to go either way, but sometimes not based on what actually happened on the field.