NCAA Draft Class Imports

[LowerWolf]

Which has been better so far: Imported classes from NCAA or generated classes from Madden?

[Sbarnes1178]

I don't find this to be too far off if you're referring to the 2013 class out of NCAA. This years QB crop is thought to rival 83 (Elway, Kelly, Marino) and be better than the RGIII, Luck class. Just off the top of my head you have Boyd, Murray, McCarron, Lynch, Carr, Fales, and some are projecting Morris of Miami in the top 2 rounds. This is without even factoring Bridgewater, Manziel, Miller, or Mariota.

Don't think it's that far off.

[redsfan4life]

Quote: Originally Posted by Sbarnes1178

I don't find this to be too far off if you're referring to the 2013 class out of NCAA. This years QB crop is thought to rival 83 (Elway, Kelly, Marino) and be better than the RGIII, Luck class. Just off the top of my head you have Boyd, Murray, McCarron, Lynch, Carr, Fales, and some are projecting Morris of Miami in the top 2 rounds. This is without even factoring Bridgewater, Manziel, Miller, or Mariota. Don't think it's that far off.

The 2015 Imported Class I tried was the same though.

In my 2014 class UNC's QB Renner went #1 overall..something is clearly a miss. I think it is the QB accuracies.

[Sturzinator]

Are there any surprises in the imported classes? I like how the gems and busts are planted in the M25 pre-made classes, but I don't like the sound of the speed and other non sensical ratings issues I have heard of.

One of the downsides of the NCAA imports in years past was that the ratings started high in the first round and got progressively worse in each subsequent round.

Can anyone with imported NCAA classes elaborate on these points ?

Thanks

[buttonyjeff2009]

If you use NCAA Class Imports do they still have story lines for the players?

[nwfdwill]

Quote: Originally Posted by buttonyjeff2009

If you use NCAA Class Imports do they still have story lines for the players?

No they do not. You'll see a couple of tweets here and there during draft and a news story on the person expected to be taken first, but that's about it.

Sent from my HTCEVOV4G using Tapatalk 4

[ajk49er]

well. you don't so much get surprises, but the personalty is all over the map, so is the development ratings. And you may get a 70 overall in rd 4 at HB, but can get a player at another position rated lower than that HB, who is in the high 70's

it has more to do with how many are imported at each position etc, but at the same time it does give a little bit of that unknown quality.

[og236]

I had AJ McCarron go #1 overall to the jaguars , he shouldn't go ahead of Teddy Bridgewater or Tajh Boyd !!! Lol