Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

[GisherJohn24]

Madden 10 is my favorite, then probably 11 then probably 13. I did not like 12. Madden 25 was okay, but I thought it was better on next gen.

[JH823Opsport]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

My Top 3 PS3 Madden Games:

1. Madden NFL 12
2. Madden NFL 15
3. Madden NFL 25

[Purk1981]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

Xbox 360
Madden 11
Madden 25
Madden 12

OG Xbox
Madden 2003
Madden 2005
Madden 2002
Madden 2007

Revisited and updated*

[gr18]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

12 was my favorite. Didn't like the limitations with 13 so continued with 12 until I got a current system.

10 was my next favorite but when I tried playing it a few years after I didn't think it played as well.

[nflrocks24]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

Easily Madden 17 and not even close. The most accurate game to real football ever. The players and teams play like they do in real life and can not stop playing it. An improved NCAA 14 pretty much. The only thing I wish was better was the franchise mode. Madden 04-07 had an unbelievable franchise mode. My favorite's for franchise.

[nflrocks24]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

Madden 10 is my favorite, then probably 11 then probably 13. I did not like 12. Madden 25 was okay, but I thought it was better on next gen.

How do not like 12? 12 is the second best game on that generation. 12 also fundememtaly represents simulation football better than 13 and 11 by a mile. 11 had no defense and 13 tackling was awful. And there was so many bugs in 13. Not disagreeing or arguing with you but shocked that you don't like 12 the slight least. Though it has its bugs as well. 10 I agree a little. That had good gameplay for back in it's hey-day. Now it's outdated for me though it's still better that the PS4 Madden games.

[GisherJohn24]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

How do not like 12? 12 is the second best game on that generation. 12 also fundememtaly represents simulation football better than 13 and 11 by a mile. 11 had no defense and 13 tackling was awful. And there was so many bugs in 13. Not disagreeing or arguing with you but shocked that you don't like 12 the slight least. Though it has its bugs as well. 10 I agree a little. That had good gameplay for back in it's hey-day. Now it's outdated for me though it's still better that the PS4 Madden games.

I don't know bro it's been awhile so maybe I need to break it out again and see if I if I missed something awesome. It's been quite a while


Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[GisherJohn24]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

How do not like 12? 12 is the second best game on that generation. 12 also fundememtaly represents simulation football better than 13 and 11 by a mile. 11 had no defense and 13 tackling was awful. And there was so many bugs in 13. Not disagreeing or arguing with you but shocked that you don't like 12 the slight least. Though it has its bugs as well. 10 I agree a little. That had good gameplay for back in it's hey-day. Now it's outdated for me though it's still better that the PS4 Madden games.

I broke out 9 and 12 this weekend. I think I like 09 over 12 for some reason. If you get a chance, try to get a hold of Madden 09. I'd like to hear your impressions on the gameplay. There is a small community who still says 09 is the best.

[Earl1963]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

Loving the animations in Madden 2001. Totally addicted to this game right now.

[stinkubus]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

How do not like 12? 12 is the second best game on that generation. 12 also fundememtaly represents simulation football better than 13 and 11 by a mile. 11 had no defense and 13 tackling was awful. And there was so many bugs in 13. Not disagreeing or arguing with you but shocked that you don't like 12 the slight least. Though it has its bugs as well. 10 I agree a little. That had good gameplay for back in it's hey-day. Now it's outdated for me though it's still better that the PS4 Madden games.

M12 had ridiculous warping. They should've changed Charles Woodson's name to Great Tiger because he was able to move about in a similar fashion.

The AI in that game was completely helpless against vertical routes. A simple TE streak could not be covered by M2M or any of the zones in the game. Even when usered your timing had to be perfect when attempting to undercut the route.

The user was also free to spam strip attempts in M12 since the strip ball function doubled as a tackle button.

I'm shocked to hear that anyone at all liked M10. Wasn't that the version where flat zones couldn't cover anything and you could just spam throws to the HB all game long?

If I had to pick one it would be M11 or M25, but honestly neither were very good games.

The 360/PS3 era represents, to me, several years of lost development that we'll never get back. By far the biggest reason the game lags behind its potential today.

[sinthros]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

M12 had ridiculous warping. They should've changed Charles Woodson's name to Great Tiger because he was able to move about in a similar fashion.

The AI in that game was completely helpless against vertical routes. A simple TE streak could not be covered by M2M or any of the zones in the game. Even when usered your timing had to be perfect when attempting to undercut the route.

The user was also free to spam strip attempts in M12 since the strip ball function doubled as a tackle button.

I'm shocked to hear that anyone at all liked M10. Wasn't that the version where flat zones couldn't cover anything and you could just spam throws to the HB all game long?

If I had to pick one it would be M11 or M25, but honestly neither were very good games.

The 360/PS3 era represents, to me, several years of lost development that we'll never get back. By far the biggest reason the game lags behind its potential today.

Pretty sure everyone loves Madden 12 due to franchise mode (I'm one of those people). Less about the gameplay itself.

[SonOfEd]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

Jumped back in to M12 and having a blast. So many options to tweak gameplay to your liking, especially with the priority sliders.

[GisherJohn24]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

I never gave 12 a chacne, but's it's pretty darn fun. IF you can, find yourself a copy of Madden 09, honsetly amazed how well that game holds up. Graphics aren't the best, but the gameplay is really really good. Also very smart AI. I believe smarter than what we got in the next gen games.

[chargerrich]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

The answer is easy

360/PS3 - M12

PS2 - M07

[hyacinth1]

Re: Favorite madden on 360 and ps3?

Madden 10 and Madden 12

Madden 10 - most balanced Madden maybe ever. Running the ball was great. Presentation was excellent. I think it even had halftime highlights from other games.

Madden 12 - the full package. Great graphics, presentation, gameplay, franchise. Maybe not as balanced as Madden 10 but fun factor was off the charts. I even remember when I first played Madden 12 I knew off the bat this was going to be a classic Madden game.

Can't go wrong with either.