Fake Player Guide - All Teams

[ClickClickZoom]

Okay, folks. I've been working on this since the game dropped and there's still plenty of work to do.

The following is a list of all the rookie prospects I could find using a variety of sources (primarily baseball america and the minor league baseball website).

Hopefully you guys can add on.

*Top 10 prospects for their respective team.

Angels

P Jordan Walden #15 (AA) - 6'5, 220, R-R, 11/16/1987* = P Aaron Wells #31 (A)
OF Peter Bourjos #8 (AA) - 6'1, 180, R-R, 3/31/1987* = CF Brandon Barker #25 (A)
P Trevor Reckling #30 (A)- 6'1, 195, L-L, 5/22/1989* = P Tim Robertson #31 (AA)
P Sean O'Sullivan #40 (AA) - 6'1, 220, R-R, 9/1/1987* = P James Oliver #70 (A)
C Hank conger #24 (AA) - 6'0, 205, S-R, 1/29/1988* = C Harry Cobb #17 (A)
1B Mark Trumbo #25 (AA) 6'4, 220, R-R, 1/16/1986* = 3B Mike Taylor #35 (A)
P Anthony Ortega #31 (AAA) - 6'0, 170, R-R, 8/24/1985* = P Jamie Nance #83 (A)
SS Andrew Romine #4 (A) 6'1, 180, S-R, 12/24/1985 = SS Mozz(something or other) (AA)
P David Herndon #35 (AA) 6'5, 230, R-R, 9/4/1985 = P Clint Hamilton #87 (A)
C Anel De Los Santos #10 (A) 6', 190, R-R, 6/19/1988 = C Jake Colon #96 (A)


Astros

C Jason Castro #10 (A) 6'3, 210, L-R, 6/18/1987* = C Rudolph Bratcher #71 (A)
P Bud Norris #20 (AAA) 6'0, 225, R-R, 3/2/1985* = P Royce Mullis #69 (A)
3B Chris Johnson #12 (AAA) 6'3, 220, R-R, 10/1/1984* = 3B Rodolfo Hidalgo #65 (A)
P Polin Trinidad #26 (AA) 6'3, 195, L-L, 11/19/1984 = P Ernie Torcato #82 (AA)
SS Tommy Manzella #2 (AAA) 6'2, 200, R-R, 4/16/1983 = SS Nelson McDonald #67 (A)
OF Josh Flores #13 (AA) 6'0, 200, R-R, 11/18/1985 = LF James Friedberg #21 (A)
OF Yordany Ramirez (AAA) 6'1, 200, R-R, 7/31/1984 = RF Yhency Roban #30 (A)

Athletics

SS Adrian Cardenas #12 (AA) 6'0, 185, L-R, 10/10/1987* = SS Craig Borland #70 (A)
1B/3B/OF Chris Carter #33 (AA) 6'4, 225, R-R, 12/18/1986* = 1B James Blumberg #75 (A)
P Vin Mazzaro #38 (AAA) 6'1, 215, R-R, 9/27/1986* = P Oscar Munoz #74 (A)
2B Jemile Weeks 5'10, 175, S-R, 1/26/1998 = 2B Adam White #53 (A)
P James Simmons #40 (AAA) 6'3, 220, R-R, 9/29/1986* = P Alvin Selkirk #68 (A)
P Henry Rodriguez (AAA) 6'0, 210, R-R, 2/25/1987 = P Alex Reed #63 (A)
OF Javier Herrera #5 (AA) 5'11, 225, R-R, 4/9/1985 = CF Jared Henson #65 (A)
1B/OF Sean Doolittle #21 (AAA) 6'3, 190, L-L, 9/26/1986 = 1B Mark (A)

Blue Jays

C J.P. Arencibia #44 (AAA) 6'0, 215, R-R, 1/5/1986* = C Billy Austin #9 (A)
1B David Cooper #18 (AA) 6'0, 200, L-L, 2/12/1987* 1B Mason Bernero # 68 (A)
P Brad Mills #49 (AAA) 5'11, 185, L-L, 3/5/1985* = P Jake Lemon #66 (A)
2B/3B Bradley Emaus #4 (AA) 5'11, 210, R-R, 3/28/1986* = 2B Matt Descent #69 (A)
C Brian Jeroloman #8 (AA) 5'11, 200, L-R, 5/10/1985 = C Rick Hayden #12 (A)

Braves

P Tommy Hanson #32 (AAA) 6'6, 210, R-R, 8/28/1986* = P Tim Harikkala #73 (A)
RF Jason Heyward #34 (A) 6'4, 220, L-L, 8/9/1989* = RF James Hunter #77 (A)
1B Frederick "Freddie" Feeman #12 (A) 6'5, 220, L-R, 9/12/1989* = 1B Devon Frenn #76 (A)
P Kris Medlen #20 (AAA) 5'10, 175, S-R, 10/7/1985* = P Ed Martin #72 (A)
OF Cody Johnson #17 (A) 6'5, 195, L-R, 8/18/1988 = CF Joe Jordan #24 (A)
P Todd Redmond #30 (AAA) 6'3, 215, R-R, 5/17/1985 = P Tug Rolls #66 (A)
3B Van Pope #8 (AAA) 6'0, 200, R-R, 2/26/1984 = 3B Victor Pablo #8 (AA)
SS Brandon Hicks #7 (AA) 6'2, 200, R-R, 9/14/1985 = SS Bill Harper #75 (A)

Brewers

P Jeremy Jeffress #20 (AA) 6'0, 197, R-R, 9/21/1987* (Closer) = P Jake Jacobson #19 (A)
LF Lorenzo Cain #18 (AA) 6'2, 185, R-R, 4/13/1986* = CF Adam Casey #88 (A)
OF Cole Gillespie #25 (A) 6'1, 205, R-R, 6/20/1984* = LF Ed Koontz #30 (AAA)
C Jonathan Lucroy #6 (AA) 6'0, 185, R-R, 6/13/1986* = C Seth Kaneko #87 (A)
P Cody Scarpetta #15 (A) 6'3, 240, R-R, 8/25/1988 = P Rey Rodriguez #72 (AA)
RF Brendan Katin #39 (AAA) 6'1, 235, R-R, 1/28/1983 = RF Bryce Kent #41 (AAA)

Cardinals

3B Brett Wallace #25 (AA) 6'1, 245, L-R, 8/26/1986* = 3B Tim Thomas #84 (A)
P Jess Todd #38 (AAA) 5'11, 210, R-R, 4/20/1986* = P Alex Townsend #76 (A)
C Bryan Anderson #24 (AAA) 6'1, 200, L-R, 12/16/1986* = C Cole Abernathy #87 (A)
P Clayton Mortensen #40 (AAA) 6'4, 180, R-R, 4/10/1985* = P Jolbert Lucero #74 (A)
2B Jarrett Hoffpauir #12 (AAA) 5'9, 175, R-R, 6/18/1983* = 2B J.P. Hendricks #70 (AA)
P Fernando Salas (AAA) 6'2, 200, R-R, 5/30/1985 = P Amos Stanley #72 (A)
SS Tyler Green #35 (AAA) 6'2, 180, R-R, 8/17/1983 = SS Taylor Gerstmann #67 (AA)

Cubs

3B Josh Vitters #12 (A) 6'3, 200, R-R, 8/27/1989* = 3B James Verne #35 (A)
P Andrew Cashner #70 (MLB) 6'6, 210, R-R, 9/11/1986* = P Byron Brawn #70 (A)
C Wellington Castillo #16 (AA) 6'0, 200, R-R, 4/24/1987* = C J.T. Castillo #72 (A)
P Esmailin Caridad #43 (AAA) 5'10, 195, R-R, 10/28/1983 = P Mark Gergmann #71 (A)
SS Darwin Barney #6 (AA) 5'10, 180, R-R, 11/8/1985 = SS Darryl Bratcher #65 (AA)
LF/CF Tyler Colvin #17 (A) 6'3, 190, L-L, 9/5/1985 = RF Trent Cook #21 (AA)

D-Backs

P Jarrod Parker #20 (A) 6'1, 180, R-R, 11/24/1988* = P Jim Procopio #60 (A)
CF Gerardo Parra #8 (AA) 5'11, 195, L-L, 5/6/1987* = CF Clay Parsons #74 (A)
P Daniel Schlereth #25 (AA) 6'0, 210, L-L, 5/9/1986* (closer) = Tim Riker #70 (A)
P Cesar Valdez #43 (AAA) 6'2, 200, R-R, 3/17/1985* = P Jake Towell #43 (A)
SS Pedro Ciriaco #2 (AA) 6'0, 160, R-R, 9/27/1985 = SS Pablo Carlos #63 (A)

Dodgers

SS/2B Ivan DeJesus, Jr. (AA) 5'11, 176, R-R, 5/1/1987* = SS Randy Carter #87 (A)
P Travis Schlichting (AAA) 6'4, 190, R-R, 10/19/1984 = P Jermaine Settle #80 (A)
CF/RF Jamie Hoffman #34 (AA) 6'3, 220, R-R, 8/20/1984 = CF Clyde Heap #77 (AA)
CF Xavier Paul #30 (AAA) 6'0, 195, L-R, 2/25/1985 = LF Jerry Peck #75 (A)

Giants

P Madison Bumgarner #17 (A) 6'5, 215, R-L, 8/1/1989* = P Mark Baker #62 (AA)
C Buster Posey #7 (A) 6'2, 195, R-R, 3/27/1987* = C Aron Penn #28 (A)
1B Angel Villalona #29 (A) 6'3, 200, R-R, 8/13/1990* = 3B Anatol Verzosa #30 (A)
OF/LF Eddy Martinez-Esteve (AA) 6'2, 215, R-R, 7/14/1983 = LF Eric Malone #8 (A)
P Waldis Joaquin #49 (AA) 6'2, 235, R-R, 12/25/1986 = P Yhency Hessman #63 (A)
C Jackson Williams #35 (AA) 5'11, 200, R-R, 5/14/1986 = C CLayton Ward #73 (A)

Indians

C Carlos Santana #41 (AA) 5'11, 190, S-R, 4/8/1986* - C Rhianna Rivera (AA)
OF Matt LaPorta #13 (AAA) 6'2, 210, R-R, 1/8/1985* - LF Mark Lowry
1B Beau Mills #24 (AA) 6'3, 220, L-R, 8/15/1986* = 1B Juan Lucero (A)
OF/1B Michael Brantley (AAA) 6'2, 200, L-L, 5/15/1987* = LF Anderson Blackburn (A)
C Wyatt Toregas #30 (AAA) 5'11, 200, R-R, 12/2/1982 = C Weslery Towell (AAA)
P David Huff #12 (AAA) 6'2, 190, L-L, 8/22/1984* = P Bobby Holt (A)
P Adam Miller #48 6'4, 200, R-R, 11/26/1984* (Closer) - Aaron Mason (AA)

Mariners

OF Greg Halman #25 (AA) 6'4, 190, R-R, 8/26/1987* - Chip Hidalgo (A)
P Phillippe Aumont #27 (A) 6'7, 220, L-R, 1/7/1989* - Preston Almonte (A)
SS/2B Carlos Trunfel #13 (AA) 5'11, 175, R-R, 2/27/1990* - Cesar Tobias (A)
C Adam Moore #9 (AA) 6'3, 220, R-R, 5/8/1984* - Jerry Luce (A)

Marlins

OF Mike Stanton #44 (A) 6'5, 225, R-R, 11/8/1989* - Harry Stairs (A)
1B Logan Morrison #7 (AA) 6'2, 215, L-L, 8/25/1987* - Gil Mannsell (A)
3B Matt Dominguez #33 (A) 6'2, 190, R-R, 8/28/1989* - Mike Del Santo (AA)
C Kyle Skipworth #8 (A) 6'3, 195, L-R, 3/1/1990* - Dave Strayer (A)
2B Chris Coghlan #8 (AAA) 6'1, 195, L-R, 6/18/1985* - Frankie Borders (AA)
P Jose Ceda (AA) 6'4, 275, R-R, 1/28/1987* - Rod Brawn (A)
OF John Raynor #4 (AAA) 6'2, 185, R-R, 1/4/1984 - Clint Roban (A)
Brett Hayes #9 (AAA) 6'1, 200, R-R, 2/13/1984 - Bruce Heiner (AA)
P Sean West #29 (AA) 6'8, 200 L-L, 6/15/1986* - Sam Wood (A)
P Aaron Thompson #45 (AA) 6'3, 195, L-L, 2/28/1987 - Alex Thorman (A)
Mets

LF Fernando Martinez #3 (AAA) 6'1, 190, L-R, 10/10/1988* - Felipe Marrero (AA)
P Dillon Gee #29 (AAA) 6'1, 195, R-R, 4/28/1986 - Mickey Holt (A)
C Mike Nickeas #9 (AA) 6'0, 210, R-R, 2/13/1983 - Max Northrop (AA)

Nationals

P Ross Detwiler #18 (AA) 6'5, 185, R-L, 3/6/1986* - Rick Durocher (A)
RF/LF Destin Hood (GCL) 6'1, 190, R-R, 4/3/1990* - Clarence Heap (A)
SS Ian Desmond #9 (AA) 6'2, 185, R-R, 9/20/1985 - Issac Downs (A)

Orioles

C Matt Wieters #32 (AAA) 6'5, 230, S-R, 5/21/1986* - Mark Weathers
P Chris Tillman #22 (AAA) 6'5, 195, R-R, 4/14/1988* - Cary Toombs (A)
P Brian Matusz #15 (A) 6'5, 200, L-L, 2/11/1987* - Brent Mount (A)
P Jake Arrieta #34 (AA) 6'4, 225, R-R, 3/6/1986* - Jim Armas (A)
OF Nolan Reimold #29 (AAA) 6'5, 205, R-R, 10/12/1983* - Nick Rice (A)
P Brandon Erbe #23 (AA) 6'4, 180, R-R, 12/25/1987* - Brian Eppes (A)
3B/OF Billy Rowell (A) 6'5, 205, L-R, 9/10/1988* - Bart Romano (A)
SS Blake Davis (AAA) 5'11, 165, L-R, 12/22/1983 - James Cassulo (AAA)
1B Brandon Snyder #29 (AA) 6'2, 215, R-R, 11/23/1986* - Brad Sharp (A)

Padres

1B Kyle Blanks #46 (AAA) 6'6, 270, R-R, 9/11/1986 * - Kent Biddle (A)
P Mat Latos #39 (A) 6'5, 210, R-R, 12/9/1987 * - Stuart Knott (A)
OF Cedric Hunter #23 (AA) 5'10, 185, L-L 3/10/1988* - Charles Holler (A)

Phillies

P Carlos Carrasco #40 (AAA) 6'3, 215, R-R, 3/21/1987* - Cesar Chacon (A)
SS Jason Donald #9 (AAA) 6'1, 190, R-R, 9/4/1984* - Jeremy Dodge (AA)
OF MIchael Taylor #40 (AA) 6'6, 250, R-R, 12/19/1985* Jack Martin (AA)

Pirates

3B Pedro Alvarez #24 (A) 6'3, 235, L-R, 2/6/1987* - James Astacio (A)
LF/CF Andrew McCutchen (AAA) 5'11, 175, R-R, 10/10/1986* - Adrian McDonald (A)
OF JOse Tabata #31 (AA) 5'11, 215, R-R, 8/12/1988* - Juan Tavarez (A)
P Brad Lincoln #18 (AA) 6'0, 215, L-R, 5/25/1985* - Bret Lemon (A)
P Ronald Uviedo #45 (A) 6'1, 160, R-R, 10/7/1986 - JOshua Taylor (A)
P Daniel Moskos #41 (AA) 6'1, 210, R-L, 4/28/1986 - David Mullis (A)
P Jeff Sues #37 (AA) 6'4, 230, R-R, 6/8/1983* - Billy Scott (AA)
P Daniel McCutchen #17 (AAA) 6'2, 215, R-R, 9/26/1982* - Andres Madia (AAA)
3B Neil Walker #24 (AAA) 6'3, 215, S-R, 9/10/1985* - Norm Williams (AA)
2B Shelby Ford #5 (AAA) 6'3, 185, S-R, 12/15/1984* - Sean Fung (A)
C Steve Lerud #15 (AA) 6'1, 210, L-R, 10/13/1984 - Sheldon Lloyd (A)

Rangers

P Neftali Feliz #54 (AAA) 6'3, 180, R-R, 5/2/1988* - Chad Fortunato (A)
P Derek Holland #45 (MLB) 6'2, 185, S-L, 10/9/1986* - Darren Halter (MLB)
1B Justin Smoak #12 (AA) 6'3, 200, S-L, 12/5/1986* - Chris Snyder (AA)
OF Julio Borbon #6 (AAA) 6'1, 180, L-L, 2/20/1986* - Adam Bain (A)

Rays

SS Tim Beckham #26 (A) 6'0, 190, R-R, 1/27/1990* - Tom Baker (A)
P Wade Davis #33 (AAA) 6'5, 220, R-R, 9/7/1985* = Wayne Dixon (A)
P Matt Moore #36 (A) 6'2, 205, L-L, 6/18/1989* - Glendon Malone (A)
P Jeremy Hellickson #18 (AA) 6'1, 185, R-R, 4/8/1987* - James Harper (A)
P Jake McGee #57 (AAA) 6'3, 190, L-L, 8/6/1986* (closer) - Jered McNurlin (A)
C Christian Lopez (AAA) 6'1, 185, R-R, 10/10/1984 - Chauncey Luce (A)

Red Sox

1B Lars Anderson #21 (AA) 6'4, 215, L-L 9/25/1987* - Leo Allen (A)
P Nick Hagadone 6'5, 230, L-L, 1/1/1986* - Mickey Rivas (A)
P Daniel Bard #31 (AAA) 6'4, 200, R-R, 6/25/1985* - Dave Baker (A)
LF/CF Josh Reddick (AA) 6'2, 180, L-R, 2/19/1987* - Courtney Redman (A)
C Mark Wagner #5 (AA) 6'1, 205, R-R, 6/11/1984 = Max Wood (AA)
SS Argenis Diaz #3 (AA) 5'11, 155, R-R, 2/12/1987 - Jeremy Carter (A)

Reds

1B Yonder Alonso #19 (A) 6'2, 215, L-R, 4/8/1987* - Jamie Abbot (A)
SS/1B/3B Todd Frazier #30 (AA) 6'3, 220, R-R, 2/12/1986* - Jim Hammond (A)
CF Drew Stubbs #7 (AAA) 6'4, 205, R-R, 10/4/1984 * - Dean Stark (A)
SS Chris Valaika #64 (MLB) 6'0, 215, R-R, 8/14/1985* - Max Terry (A)
3B Juan Francisco #34 (AA) 6'2, 180, L-R, 6/24/1987* - Chris Gossard (A)
C Devin Mesoraco #37 (A) 6'1, 220, R-R, 6/19/1988* - Tug Lane (A)
P Jordan Smith #9 (AA) 6'4, 220, R-R, 2/4/1986 - Aubrey Semsey (A)

Rockies

P Jhoulys Chacin #45 (AA) 6'3, 200, R-R, 1/7/1988* - Ralph Blevins (A)
C Wilin Rosario #20 (A) 5'11, 190, R-R, 2/23/1989* - Jonathan Rivera (A)
SS Hector Gomez (A) 6'2, 180, R-R, 3/5/1988* - Max Hart (A)
P Esmil Rogers #38 (AA) 6'1, 150, R-R, 8/14/1985* - Alex Rogers (A)
C Michael McKenry #9 (AA) 5'10, 200, R-R, 3/4/1985* - Jered Morris (AA)

Royals

SS Mike Moustakas #23 (A) 6'0, 195, L-R, 9/11/1988* - Matthew Michaels (A)
1B Eric Hosmer #44 (A) 6'5, 215, L-L, 10/24/1989* - Ellis Houston (A)
P Daniel Cortes #29 (AA) 6'6, 215, R-R, 3/4/1987* - Lance Brown (A)
LF/CF Derreck Robinson #11 (A) 5'11, 170, S-L, 9/29/1987 - Tim Phelps (A)
CF Jose Duarte #26 (AA) 5'10, 165, R-R, 3/7/1985 - Juan Dame (AA)

Tigers

SS Cale Iorg #18 (AA) 6'2, 180, R-R, 9/6/1985* = Jim Hurt (A)
2B Scott Sizemore #10 (AA) 6'0, 185, R-R, 1/4/1985* - Juan Sanchez (A)
P Jonathan Kibler #38 (AA) 6'4, 215, L-L, 8/10/1986 - Dominic Jameson (AA)
C Jeff Kunkel #7 (AA) 5'11, 200, S-R, 3/11/1983 - Donald Johnstone (A)

Twins

C Wilson Ramos #40 (AA) 6'0, 220, R-R, 8/10/1987* - James Ryan (A)
3B Danny Valencia #22 (AA) 6'2, 210, R-R, 9/19/1984* - Marty Toliver (A)
P Anthony Swarzak #40 (AAA) 6'4, 225, R-R, 9/10/1985* - Adam Scott (A)
P Kevin Mulvey #12 (AAA) 6'2, 195, R-R, 5/26/1985* - Kristopher Mears (A)
P Deolis Guerra #43 (A) 6'5, 200, R-R, 4/17/1989 - Domingo Guardado (A)
SS Trevor Plouffe # 1 (AAA) 6'2, 195, R-R, 6/15, 1986 - Tavis Paul (AA)

White Sox

SS Gordon Beckham #5 (AA) 6'0, 190, R-R, 9/16/1986* - Paul Allen (A)
P Aaron Poreda #55 (AA) 6'6, 240, L-L, 10/1/1986* - Alan Palmer (A)
1B Brandon Allen #22 (AA) 6'2, 235, L-R, 2/12/1986* - Brandon Andrews (A)
RF/LF Justin Greene #11 (A) 6'0, 185, R-R, 10/10/1985 - Anastacio Guzman (A)
C Cole Armstrong #34 (AAA) 6'3, 210, L-R, 8/24/1983* - Dave Acosta (AA)
CF/RF Sal Sanchez #40 (A) 6'6, 195, R-R, 9/13/1985 - Sandy Santiago

Yankees

OF Austin Jackson LF/CF #24 (AAA) 6'1, 185, R-R, 2/1/1987* - Alton Jarvis (A)
C Jesus Montero #45 (A) 6'4, 225, R-R, 11/28/1989* - Jeff McNurlin (A)
P Andrew Brackman #33 (A) 6'10, 240, R-R, 12/4/1985* - Mark Anderson (A)
C Austin Romine #12 (A) 6'2, 210, R-R, 11/22/1988* - Mendy Planter (A)
P Mark Melancon #41 (AAA) 6'2, 215, R-R, 3/28/1985* (closer) - Jim Malone (A)
3B Chris Malec #17 (AA) 5'11, 195, S-R, 8/28/1982 - Chad Mills (AA)
P Christian Garcia (AA) 6'5, 215, R-R, 8/24/1985 - Kevin Halter (A)

[DonkeyJote]

Re: Fake Player Guide - All Teams

There's a C.Hall for the Mississippi Braves that might be Gorkys Hernandez.

[ClickClickZoom]

Re: Fake Player Guide - All Teams

Either the height, weight, handedness or b-day doesn't match.

[cubsfan203]

Re: Fake Player Guide - All Teams

You're missing a couple of the Rangers people in the game. I can think of at least two more pitchers that I found when I went through them. There were some others that matched everything, but the b-days were wrong.

[ClickClickZoom]

Re: Fake Player Guide - All Teams

Yea, there are a few where the month and date don't match (all of which have b-days of 1/1/19--) but the year/age do.

There's a slew of players I'm missing. Any and all faker players with a b-day other than 1/1/19-- have real life counter parts. I mostly wanted to change the names of the top prospects for each team but had a hard time doing that.

[cubsfan203]

Re: Fake Player Guide - All Teams

Kasey Kiker and Michael Schlact were the two I was thinking of. They at least have the correct height/weight/age.

[utsax05]

Re: Fake Player Guide - All Teams

The great thing I have discovered about the minor league players this year, is that a great majority of them have the same fake name as they did in 2K8.

[flangoid]

Re: Fake Player Guide - All Teams

Blue Jays

C J.P. Arencibia #44 (AAA) 6'0, 215, R-R, 1/5/1986* = C Billy Austin #9 (A)
1B David Cooper #18 (AA) 6'0, 200, L-L, 2/12/1987* 1B Mason Bernero # 68 (A)
P Brad Mills #49 (AAA) 5'11, 185, L-L, 3/5/1985* = P Jake Lemon #66 (A)
2B/3B Bradley Emaus #4 (AA) 5'11, 210, R-R, 3/28/1986* = 2B Matt Descent #69 (A)
C Brian Jeroloman #8 (AA) 5'11, 200, L-R, 5/10/1985 = C Rick Hayden #12 (A)
(A)

Great stuff CCZ. I'm a huge Blue Jays fan so let me take your template and add all the others I've found. I've taken the 2K, May 8 Living Roster Update and gone through every player on the Jays through to A-Dunedin.

I'm not certain of the Top 10 Prospects, so I haven't included that but here's what I've found:

P Marty McLeary #?? (AA) 6'3, 225, R-R, 10/26/1974 = P Larry Murray (AAA)
OF Jason Lane #24 (AAA) 6'2, 225, R-L, 12/22/1976 = OF Jordan Logan (AAA)
OF Russ Adams #21 (AAA) 6'0, 200, L-R, 8/30/1980 = SS Jay Aquino (AAA) (Listed as a SS but primarily playing LF now)
3B Scott Campbell #6 (AAA) 6'0, 190, L-R, 9/25/1984 = 2B Hideki Chow (AA) (Listed as 2B but he plays 3B)
C Kyle Phillips #26 (AA) 6'0, 225, L-R, 4/3/1984 = C Cliff Pats (AA) (Currently with AAA Las Vegas, injury call-up)
P Davis Romero #52 (AAA) 5'10, 170, L-L, 3/30/1983 = P Emilio Qualls (A)
P Luis Perez #27 (AA) 6'-0, 205, L-L, 1/20/1985 = P Doug Peete (A)
1B/DH Brian Dopirak #44 (AA) 6'4, 230, R-R, 12/20/1983 = 1B Kip Carter (A)
SS Chris Gutierrez #3 (AA) 5'10, 170, R-R, 3/12/1984 = 3B Cliff Greisinger (A)

The ones listed above I am quite certain are correct, there's another I suspect is correct although the birth date is wrong, everything else lines up:

OF Aaron Matthews #12 (AAA) 5'10, 200, R-R, 1/1/1983 = OF Amos Mays (A)

2K has revised the Living Rosters but if you're working with an older set, you may not have these two changes:

P Robert Ray #60 (MLB-currently) 6'5, 195, R-R, 1/21/1984 = P Reed Rose (A)
P Brett Cecil #27 (MLB-currently) 6'2, 225, R-L, 7/2/1986 = P Erick Boenisch (A) (NOT Bronson Crain as so many have suggested)