Official MLB 2K10 Impressions (360/PS3)

[brendanrfoley]

MY last few games played, I've had a big problem; CPU hitters swing at EVERYTHING. I didn't have this issue until the most recent update; am I alone?

[Gotmadskillzson]

Basically.........the commentary is about the only great thing about this game. Everything else about the game is either average or subpar. Pitching and batting is annoying to me. I don't want to do all that movement with sticks just to throw a pitch or swing a bat.

Lack of homers, errors, injuries.......I don't know to me 2k8 was better then this year and last year version.

[Juiceman]

I am a huge 2k10 supporter, but I think I finally am coming around to the fact that I just can't get into this game without having control of the fielders. I caved and bought The Show last week and while I'm not comparing the two game I am stating that having complete control of your fielders really makes a huge difference. Any other baseball game would have made me realize this; it just happens it was the show I played. It's hard to go back to 2k10 when the fielder's are 99% automatically controlled. To me there is really no acceptable reason for auto fielding like this and because 2k10 was the only game I was playing I wasn't able to realize how much I was missing out on. Now I realize it's a necessity in any baseball game to have manual fielding. Guess I had forgotten this. Still a fun baseball game, but much is taken away.

[duke776]

Quote: Originally Posted by Juiceman

I am a huge 2k10 supporter, but I think I finally am coming around to the fact that I just can't get into this game without having control of the fielders. I caved and bought The Show last week and while I'm not comparing the two game I am stating that having complete control of your fielders really makes a huge difference. Any other baseball game would have made me realize this; it just happens it was the show I played. It's hard to go back to 2k10 when the fielder's are 99% automatically controlled. To me there is really no acceptable reason for auto fielding like this and because 2k10 was the only game I was playing I wasn't able to realize how much I was missing out on. Now I realize it's a necessity in any baseball game to have manual fielding. Guess I had forgotten this. Still a fun baseball game, but much is taken away.

I agree, this takes a lot of the fun out of the game for me. I mean it's a good game and all, but not having control of our fielders is really starting to get to me. I cannot count the number of times I have had a middle infielder start running straight for the outfield wall instead of continuing to try and field the ball. Or a first/third baseman running towards the bag when a ball is hit to them. Or how there's only certain times when the dive button works.

I have no doubt it will still be like this after the patch, but if it stays like this next year count me out.

[RoyalBoyle78]

honestly, I now have own games for both systems, and I'm pretty amazing how much better MLB is on the 360, I looks so much better and to be plays better.

[Tomba]

Quote: Originally Posted by Juiceman

I am a huge 2k10 supporter, but I think I finally am coming around to the fact that I just can't get into this game without having control of the fielders. I caved and bought The Show last week and while I'm not comparing the two game I am stating that having complete control of your fielders really makes a huge difference. Any other baseball game would have made me realize this; it just happens it was the show I played. It's hard to go back to 2k10 when the fielder's are 99% automatically controlled. To me there is really no acceptable reason for auto fielding like this and because 2k10 was the only game I was playing I wasn't able to realize how much I was missing out on. Now I realize it's a necessity in any baseball game to have manual fielding. Guess I had forgotten this. Still a fun baseball game, but much is taken away.

try out the tombasports roster in the roster thread

[Tomba]

Quote: Originally Posted by duke776

I agree, this takes a lot of the fun out of the game for me. I mean it's a good game and all, but not having control of our fielders is really starting to get to me. I cannot count the number of times I have had a middle infielder start running straight for the outfield wall instead of continuing to try and field the ball. Or a first/third baseman running towards the bag when a ball is hit to them. Or how there's only certain times when the dive button works. I have no doubt it will still be like this after the patch, but if it stays like this next year count me out.

again try out the roster I've made these issues have been fixed... check the thread in the roster area

[RoyalBoyle78]

Quote: Originally Posted by Tomba

again try out the roster I've made these issues have been fixed... check the thread in the roster area

are the rosters on 2kshares, if so what the name, who has the best sliders too?