2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

[Anglefan]

Nice to see they have Brandon Phillips stance finally. I'm am not too sure about Vottos and Hudson does not work for me for Mike Leake. Chapman wears long pants.

[crains13]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

Change Votto's stance to Napoli, its the closest one IMO.

[crains13]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

Here are some of my edits so far, they are about the same as '10.

Joey Votto- Mike Napoli
Jay Bruce- Franklin Gutierrez, or Justin Upton
Scott Rolen- Chris Woodward
Juan Francisco- Chris Snyder
Drew Stubbs- Michael Young
Chris Heisey- Omar Vizquel
Paul Janish- Chris Ianneta??
Ryan Hanigan- Gen 126
Ramon Hernandez- Lance Berkman

[findinghomer]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

Here are some of my edits so far, they are about the same as '10.

Joey Votto- Mike Napoli
Jay Bruce- Franklin Gutierrez, or Justin Upton
Scott Rolen- Chris Woodard
Juan Francisco- Chris Snyder
Drew Stubbs- Michael Young
Chris Heisey- Omar Vizquel
Paul Janish- Chris Ianneta??
Ryan Hanigan- Gen 126
Ramon Hernandez- Lance Berkman

chris heisey, scott rolen, and francisco are all on the money. leave those stock. sooooo glad they fixed phillips. i used a generic one for hanigan too, can remember off top of my head. janish stock one is decent, last year there was a generic one that had the "hand massage" thing he does, but had some body movement that wasnt exact but it was a very very good generic one. and bruce. why cant they get him right? lol. his stance is pretty generic anyway, but that broken wrist look is ridiculous. in fact i think its a glitch thats been in the game since 09. bc if you look at his edit player it does not even look like that.

[crains13]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

Rolens stance in the game isnt close to his real batting stance. Trust me, I watch 98% of the Reds games. Chris Woodward is the closest.

[findinghomer]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

sorry buddy, but "not even close" would be phillips stance from last year. rolens stance is almost dead on except for the lack of foot motion. woodwards stance has the tiny step foot motion but lacks rolens signature violent waggle. obv neither is perfect, but his stock stance is much closer. i was actually impressed with the acurracy on such a low profile player as chris heisy. slow down that bat wag, and he is on the money.

[crains13]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

sorry buddy, but "not even close" would be phillips stance from last year. rolens stance is almost dead on except for the lack of foot motion. woodwards stance has the tiny step foot motion but lacks rolens signature violent waggle. obv neither is perfect, but his stock stance is much closer. i was actually impressed with the acurracy on such a low profile player as chris heisy. slow down that bat wag, and he is on the money.

Rolens stance has too much leg/body movement, plus it he too crouched. But you can go with whatever batting stance you want...yeah but with heisey i would at least have liked them to pronnouce his last name correct.

[Monroe10]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

you guys found anything for Aroldis?

[jcmreds]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

Votto = Loney
Stubbs = gen 48
Rolen = Eckstein
Bruce = M.Holliday
Hanigan = gen 83
Janish = Boesch

Cueto = Danks
Bailey = Bonderman

I'm still trying to find something for Travis Wood. Wood needs his ratings bumped up he's horribly underrated and his pitches should be FB,cutter,changeup,slider,curve. Leake should have a cutter and a 2S fastball(both at 88 mph) instead of a 4S FB.

[crains13]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

Votto = Loney
Stubbs = gen 48
Rolen = Eckstein
Bruce = M.Holliday
Hanigan = gen 83
Janish = Boesch

Cueto = Danks
Bailey = Bonderman

I'm still trying to find something for Travis Wood. Wood needs his ratings bumped up he's horribly underrated and his pitches should be FB,cutter,changeup,slider,curve. Leake should have a cutter and a 2S fastball(both at 88 mph) instead of a 4S FB.

Nice call on Boesch for Janish.

[merslinger]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

ok dont freak out on me but what do you think about eric chaves stance for jay bruce. since he his left hand his usually rolling his left sleeve up until the pitch is enroute i think this stance works. the others mentioned dont have him back enough on his back leg or his led out straight enough. the hands look close to where he has them when he finally gets his sleeve where h wants it the only thin is it is missing the elbow movement or elbow pump right before the pitch.

[merslinger]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

sorry if this is in the wrong area but have any of you tried either of the reds lineups in roster vault. the didnt change bruce stance which leads me to think there is lack of detail. however maybe they just work on the farm system. also looking for what you guys think about the player positioning such as billy hamilton at second(i know he is often projected there by some but other say he has to much range and arm and will have to stay on the left side or move outside the infield) todd frazier in cf but do have ss as secondary and so on.

[Anglefan]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

Any suggestions for Mike Leake?

[crains13]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

Any suggestions for Mike Leake?

I had a good pitching delivery for him last year, it was a generic one...but all of the generics are different this year, number wise.

[findinghomer]

Re: 2011 MLB Cincinnati Reds Edits

nice call on the eckstein for rolen. i think thats a good mixture of the two motions he uses to reproduces the closes look. and hanigans gen 83 is also what i use it is perfect. janish had a gen one last year that was great but i cant find it this year.

ok dont freak out on me but what do you think about eric chaves stance for jay bruce. since he his left hand his usually rolling his left sleeve up until the pitch is enroute i think this stance works. the others mentioned dont have him back enough on his back leg or his led out straight enough. the hands look close to where he has them when he finally gets his sleeve where h wants it the only thin is it is missing the elbow movement or elbow pump right before the pitch.

chavez for bruce has too much waggle. bruce's stance is very generic, check out gen 42

crain, check out gen 23 for stubbs. i like it , reproduces stubbs waggle, and body rhythm.