Top 5 Third Baseman in MLB09 The Show

[Rod_Carew29]

thank you, but honestly whomever is in charge of gathering speed data, I don't feel that they have a REAL good grip on it. For the top 5 left fielders, Holliday is NOT a 60 for speed...He's just not. Now ironically, I think the others Manny, Lee, Sori...are just about where I'd have them.

Quote: Originally Posted by sask3m

There is no stat for speed so scea likely has their standard formula that they lump everyone into, stolenbases and position being the main two. I would venture to say that if Wright were playing SS or CF his speed would be rated even higher than it is. Player ratings is one area that Scea should focus more on getting right. Formulas and player generating programs are ok for stat based ratings but not for all ratings in general, that's what we look to you for Rod.

[dave_sz]

Quote: Originally Posted by SoxFan01605

I can agree with that. The truth is, I think A-Rod's more physically gifted as a fielder (better arm, quicker feet, etc) but mind f*cks some pretty standard plays...lol. EDIT: They really should have a mind-f*ck rating in The Show, now that I think about it. Of course, they can feel free to call it something else.

they can call it "what was he thinking?" rating...

[Bucksin06]

These shaky ratings are starting to concern me

[Rod_Carew29]

but again...what's the fuss?

All that is needed to be done is:

either wait till one of the roster guys here does the updated rosters (not me though, I keep my stuff under wraps)

or

just edit whaatever you have an issue with, yourself

Quote: Originally Posted by Bucksin06

These shaky ratings are starting to concern me