Advice needed on trade proposal

[johnpreyes]

In my Yankees franchise (Knights rosters), Kuroda has been inconsistent and Pettitte and Nova have been mediocre and I wanted to trade for a starting pitcher to complement CC and Pineda. I've tried trading for Greinke but failed. I'm torn between trading for either Garza, Carpenter or Tim Hudson. I'm leaning towards trading for Hudson since Atlanta is willing to accept the trade for just a couple of minor league relief pitchers.

My only worry is Hudson is primarily a groundball pitcher and the Yankees don't have the best infield defense. Any help on this would be appreciated.

[Richard.Chaffin]

Re: Advice needed on trade proposal

In my Yankees franchise (Knights rosters), Kuroda has been inconsistent and Pettitte and Nova have been mediocre and I wanted to trade for a starting pitcher to complement CC and Pineda. I've tried trading for Greinke but failed. I'm torn between trading for either Garza, Carpenter or Tim Hudson. I'm leaning towards trading for Hudson since Atlanta is willing to accept the trade for just a couple of minor league relief pitchers.

My only worry is Hudson is primarily a groundball pitcher and the Yankees don't have the best infield defense. Any help on this would be appreciated.

The trade thread, you know, that thread right below re I found your post

[johnpreyes]

Re: Advice needed on trade proposal

There's no need to be a prick.

[iRepIndiana]

The trade thread, you know, that thread right below re I found your post

I know man no need to be a smartass he simply was posting here.

[yougo1000]

Re: Advice needed on trade proposal

I would trade for Garza because he is a solid rotation cog who could win 10-15 games for you a year. While Hudson and Carpenter are older Garza is only 29.

[JWaLL]

Re: Advice needed on trade proposal

I know man no need to be a smartass he simply was posting here.

there is a thread solely designed to talk about trades so that the clutter is reduced. Learn how to use the forums before calling someone a "smartass" or a "prick"

The Official Trade Discussion Thread

[johnpreyes]

Re: Advice needed on trade proposal

Let the mods do their job. If they want to close the thread, that's their prerogative. Until then, mind your business.

[rjackson]

Re: Advice needed on trade proposal

Let the mods do their job. If they want to close the thread, that's their prerogative. Until then, mind your business.

Not trying to be a troll here, seriously. It probably will get closed and I understand what you are saying but self-policing isn't a bad thing. If it wasn't in the sticky to read before posting, I'd be on your side.

[cusefan74]

Re: Advice needed on trade proposal

I'll get us back on topic.

I wouldn't mind a ground ball pitcher at Yankee Stadium, small stadium, ground balls, sounds good to me. So for me I would want Hudson.

[Millennium]

Re: Advice needed on trade proposal

Really disappointed that people couldn't just come into the thread and point him to the correct thread. Name calling is completely unnecessary.

johnpreyes - Please use the Trade Discussion thread linked earlier in the thread.