Classic Rosters - MLB 23 - Operation Sports Forums

Recommended Videos

Collapse

Classic Rosters - MLB 23

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bostongahden
    MVP
    • Jan 2010
    • 1383

    #1

    Classic Rosters - MLB 23

    Just switching on the lights and unpacking some info here on my new roster thread as I have finally made the move to the PS5. Obviously, a bit late to the party, but better late than never.

    First of all, after only a few days of exploring MLB 23 I am blown away by the stadium creator feature as it is indeed a game changer. Like many classic roster creators, there is no escaping the reality that MLB 20 is the gold standard for classic roster variety. However, I now see that even though the number of rosters will probably never be matched on these next-gen MLB titles, the quality will certainly be much richer.

    My first project will be a more in-depth sequel of my Sensational 70s all-decade set. Due to the time it takes to make a quality roster, it is certainly understandable that classic seasons or specialty rosters are lacking. My thinking moving forward is to simply create one or two rosters for each title. I favor the all-decade sets because you get a good variety of players, and all teams are reasonably competitive. I thought I'd have to build a few stadiums, but the selection in the stadium vault is incredible. Aside from the odd tweaks here and there, not much work will have to be done. If anyone knows who consistently does quality work on stadiums, please feel free to share their ID here.

    I always have people ask how I go about creating a roster, so I'll briefly share my process. I use JTommy67s' RBU (Roster Building Utility) to rate all my players. He has a thread on here if anyone is interested in exploring this fantastic tool. It works bang on for position players in my opinion. It is effective for the pitchers as well, but I find I have to add 10-15 points in the HR, K, BB categories to boost overall ratings. The other necessity for me is The Neyer/James Guide to Pitchers. If you aren't familiar with this book, it is a terrific resource for pitching repertoires. For any pitchers I can't find in the book, I simply speculate or search the web, but over 80% of the pitchers on my spreadsheet below were found in this book.


    I will give updates here as I move along and offer info on my plans for rebranding. It's great to be back in the game!

    Sensational 70s -Rebranding Info

    Orioles
    Red Sox
    Yankees (Rebrand as Blue Jays)
    Rays (Rebrand as Yankees)
    Blue Jays (Rebrand as Brewers)

    White Sox
    Indians
    Tigers
    Royals
    Twins

    Angels
    A's
    Mariners
    Rangers
    Astros (Rebrand is users choice)

    Braves
    Marlins
    Nationals
    Mets
    Phillies

    Cubs
    Reds
    Brewers (Rebrand is users choice)
    Pirates
    Cardinals

    Diamondbacks (Rebrand as Astros)
    Rockies
    Dodgers
    Padres
    Giants

    Notes on roster:


    The Sensational 70s decade roster is a 30 man collection of the best players for each franchise throughout the 1970s. Player ratings reflect their best statistical season during the decade and likenesses and equipment should be reasonably accurate making for an enjoyable walk down memory lane. I didn’t alter pitcher hitting as these were made with the universal DH in mind.

    The minors are smattered with fringe players and guys who may have been drafted by teams but didn’t necessarily play in the majors in the 70s. Some of these extra players have not been completely adjusted because I didn’t feel it was warranted with this being a “one-and-done” season roster. I didn’t spend much time on batting stances and pitching motions as I make any necessary adjustments during gameplay. A few players have no flap helmets, but most do not. For me, that’s not a major gamebreaker as it would have led to more work than I wanted to bother with. The retired number workaround is now gone which was a bummer, but I just go to a different number that a player may have worn during their career, and that usually works. When two players wore the same number with a certain team, I used seniority and/or career success as factors for which player gets the number in question. Unfortunately, you’ll still have to reassign some of the numbers again when you start a franchise which is annoying.

    Two of the four non-era franchises need rebranding. You could use any teams you want here, and I elected to go with the Seattle Pilots for the AL Astros slot and the Chicago Hitmen for the NL Brewers slot. I left Miami and Colorado alone. I filled these four squads with an assortment of fringe/bench players and journeymen who may have dropped into the big leagues for a quick cup of coffee during the decade. Rebranding is also needed in the AL East for Milwaukee (Toronto slot), New York Yankees (Tampa Bay slot), and the Toronto Blue Jays (New York slot) to avoid losing a lot of retired numbers in the Yankee franchise slot and to return the Brewers to the American League. I did further rebranding for the Montreal Expos, New York Mets, and the Cleveland Indians to fit them with proper 70s-era uniforms. I prepared a few logo sets for some of these teams and put them in the vault. Any feedback is welcome. Enjoy!

    Adjustments needed to the original roster file in vault:
    Orioles > Brooks Robinson is listed as a switch hitter. Should be right-handed only
    Reds > Ken Griffey is listed as throwing right. Should be left
    Dodgers > Bill Buckner is listed as throwing right. Should be left


    <iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/py0JebTU2yg?si=QJe0p4qEDpaLIcmD" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" allowfullscreen></iframe>

    Electrifying 80s - Rebranding Info

    Orioles
    Red Sox
    Yankees
    Rays (Rebrand as Brewers)
    Blue Jays

    White Sox
    Indians
    Tigers
    Royals
    Twins

    Angels
    A's
    Mariners
    Rangers
    Astros (Rebrand is users choice)

    Braves
    Marlins
    Nationals
    Mets
    Phillies

    Cubs
    Reds
    Brewers (Rebrand is users choice)
    Pirates
    Cardinals

    Diamondbacks (Rebrand as Astros)
    Rockies
    Dodgers
    Padres
    Giants

    Notes on roster:


    The Electrifying 80s decade roster is a 30 man collection of the best players for each franchise throughout the 1980s. Again, as with my Sensational 70s set, I didn’t alter pitcher hitting as this set was made with the universal DH in mind. Also, players' ratings are based on their best statistical season of the decade.

    Like the 70s decade set, the 4 non-era teams are filled with fringe players from the decade. Now that the retired number fix has been uncovered, you should be able to get each players' proper numbers after you start up your franchise. Just make sure you have 30 team control and give the player his proper number. Then export the player. Once you come back to the original roster, that player's number will have changed to their rightful number.

    Even though this is a 30 man set, many of the other players on the rosters have had their ratings adjusted. The farm systems aren't robust as this is a "one and done" franchise experience. It could be built for the long haul if anyone wants to put the extra work into it, but its current construction suits me just fine. Make sure you rebrand Tampa Bay to Milwaukee and Arizona to Houston. The other two slots can be configured as you see fit. Enjoy!

    Link to Electrifying 80's trailer:



    Classic Franchise Teams V.1

    AL East
    1970 Orioles
    2018 Red Sox
    1943 Homestead Grays (Yankees slot - rebranding)
    1961 Yankees (Blue Jays slot - rebranding)
    1927 Yankees (Rays slot - rebranding)

    AL Central
    2005 White Sox
    1996 Indians (rebranding)
    1985 Royals
    1987 Twins
    1968 Tigers

    AL West
    1997 Mariners
    2022 Astros
    1973 A's
    1989 A's (Rangers slot - rebranding)
    1940 Kansas City Monarchs (Angels slot - rebranding)
    Last edited by bostongahden; 04-03-2025, 07:58 PM.
    Pitching, defense and 2 out RBIs win a lot of ball games!

    For classic sports highlights and livestream action, follow me on YouTube:
    https://www.youtube.com/@greenmonster37ft/videos
    Bluesky:
    https://bsky.app/profile/bostonrob.bsky.social
  • jemyers1975
    Pro
    • Mar 2010
    • 612

    #2
    Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

    This is so awesome , and welcome to the next Gen it's flat amazing. And if you need any help just let me know. Love this project

    Sent from my moto g play (XT2093DL) using Tapatalk

    Comment

    • bostongahden
      MVP
      • Jan 2010
      • 1383

      #3
      Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

      Originally posted by jemyers1975
      This is so awesome , and welcome to the next Gen it's flat amazing. And if you need any help just let me know. Love this project

      Sent from my moto g play (XT2093DL) using Tapatalk
      Thanks, jemyers1975. I should have also added that I am also open to collaboration on any future projects you may have in mind, so if you ever need a hand, I would be willing to get involved. Can't wait to try out your 84 set and the 1955 project.
      Pitching, defense and 2 out RBIs win a lot of ball games!

      For classic sports highlights and livestream action, follow me on YouTube:
      https://www.youtube.com/@greenmonster37ft/videos
      Bluesky:
      https://bsky.app/profile/bostonrob.bsky.social

      Comment

      • jemyers1975
        Pro
        • Mar 2010
        • 612

        #4
        Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

        He k yes I love it just released 1981 today full 93

        Sent from my moto g play (XT2093DL) using Tapatalk

        Comment

        • bostongahden
          MVP
          • Jan 2010
          • 1383

          #5
          Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

          Originally posted by jemyers1975
          He k yes I love it just released 1981 today full 93

          Sent from my moto g play (XT2093DL) using Tapatalk
          FANTASTIC! Any rebranding or specific stadiums I should be looking for?
          Pitching, defense and 2 out RBIs win a lot of ball games!

          For classic sports highlights and livestream action, follow me on YouTube:
          https://www.youtube.com/@greenmonster37ft/videos
          Bluesky:
          https://bsky.app/profile/bostonrob.bsky.social

          Comment

          • jemyers1975
            Pro
            • Mar 2010
            • 612

            #6
            Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

            TB-Mil
            Houston- team Japan
            Miami-Diablos (mexican team) under Catch237 logos
            colorado-Rieleros same as above
            Milwaukee - team Mexico
            And arizona is Houston
            Stadium wise catch237 or ATG_Baseball has amazing stadiums in the vault

            Sent from my moto g play (XT2093DL) using Tapatalk

            Comment

            • Armor and Sword
              The Lama
              • Sep 2010
              • 21559

              #7
              Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

              I am just about to start a Nifty 90’s Yankees season on 20.

              I will be following this thread……no doubt.

              You are a legend.


              Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
              Now Playing on PS5:
              NHL25 - Panthers YR1 (57-13-2)
              CFB 25 - Alabama YR8
              MLB The Show 24 - 1990 Blue Jays
              MLB The Show 25 - 2025 Yankees Year 1 (19-18)



              Follow me on Twitch
              https://www.twitch.tv/armorandsword

              Comment

              • dowie
                MVP
                • Feb 2005
                • 1995

                #8
                Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

                Originally posted by Armor and Sword
                I am just about to start a Nifty 90’s Yankees season on 20.

                I will be following this thread……no doubt.

                You are a legend.


                Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
                Armor - if you are doing a single season fantasy draft (Nifty 90s) draft, please stream the draft.

                Dowie
                Cardinals Nation - For The Lou
                Always a Tiger - Bless You Boys
                How can you not be romantic about baseball?

                Comment

                • blackhawksfan4ever19
                  MVP
                  • May 2017
                  • 1512

                  #9
                  Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

                  Boston: awesome work BTW on your ERA rosters for Show 20.

                  I see that you are making a "sensational 70's" roster for Show 23.

                  Are you going to make the other ERAS??

                  If NOT would you PLEASSSSSE do it.



                  I'd HAVE to buy Show 23 then.
                  I am the way
                  I am the light
                  I am the dark inside the night.
                  I hear your hopes
                  I feel your dreams
                  And in the dark I hear your screams
                  Don't turn away, Just take my hand
                  I'll never leave, All I ask of you, Is Believe.

                  Believe

                  Savatage - RIP Chris Oliva - April 3, 1963 – October 17, 1993

                  Comment

                  • bostongahden
                    MVP
                    • Jan 2010
                    • 1383

                    #10
                    Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

                    Originally posted by blackhawksfan4ever19
                    Boston: awesome work BTW on your ERA rosters for Show 20.

                    I see that you are making a "sensational 70's" roster for Show 23.

                    Are you going to make the other ERAS??

                    If NOT would you PLEASSSSSE do it.



                    I'd HAVE to buy Show 23 then.
                    Glad you enjoy them, blackhawks. I'm going to be doing the 70s for sure and maybe one more. It's a lot of work as I'm a one-man show, so my outlook moving forward is to do maybe a couple for each different title. For example, let's say I do the 70s and the 60s for MLB 23. If I buy MLB 24, I'll do a couple of different eras. No sense repeating the same set over and over again. Custom franchises are what this series needs. Then you can just do a certain number of teams. If I do buy MLB 24 it won't be until around this time next year. I never pay full price for these games.

                    I almost have the AL East done for my Sensational 70s set
                    Pitching, defense and 2 out RBIs win a lot of ball games!

                    For classic sports highlights and livestream action, follow me on YouTube:
                    https://www.youtube.com/@greenmonster37ft/videos
                    Bluesky:
                    https://bsky.app/profile/bostonrob.bsky.social

                    Comment

                    • blackhawksfan4ever19
                      MVP
                      • May 2017
                      • 1512

                      #11
                      Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

                      Originally posted by bostongahden
                      Glad you enjoy them, blackhawks. I'm going to be doing the 70s for sure and maybe one more. It's a lot of work as I'm a one-man show, so my outlook moving forward is to do maybe a couple for each different title. For example, let's say I do the 70s and the 60s for MLB 23. If I buy MLB 24, I'll do a couple of different eras. No sense repeating the same set over and over again. Custom franchises are what this series needs. Then you can just do a certain number of teams. If I do buy MLB 24 it won't be until around this time next year. I never pay full price for these games.

                      I almost have the AL East done for my Sensational 70s set
                      First off, if you do do 1 more for 23 might I suggest a 80's!! Era I grew up in.

                      As far as not buying Shows till they are cheap, now you sound like me. I'm STILL waiting for a little lower price.
                      I am the way
                      I am the light
                      I am the dark inside the night.
                      I hear your hopes
                      I feel your dreams
                      And in the dark I hear your screams
                      Don't turn away, Just take my hand
                      I'll never leave, All I ask of you, Is Believe.

                      Believe

                      Savatage - RIP Chris Oliva - April 3, 1963 – October 17, 1993

                      Comment

                      • Armor and Sword
                        The Lama
                        • Sep 2010
                        • 21559

                        #12
                        Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

                        Originally posted by dowie
                        Armor - if you are doing a single season fantasy draft (Nifty 90s) draft, please stream the draft.



                        Dowie


                        Playing the stock set…..it’s amazing.


                        Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
                        Now Playing on PS5:
                        NHL25 - Panthers YR1 (57-13-2)
                        CFB 25 - Alabama YR8
                        MLB The Show 24 - 1990 Blue Jays
                        MLB The Show 25 - 2025 Yankees Year 1 (19-18)



                        Follow me on Twitch
                        https://www.twitch.tv/armorandsword

                        Comment

                        • bostongahden
                          MVP
                          • Jan 2010
                          • 1383

                          #13
                          Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

                          Yeah it's also better to wait to buy games also because other creators already have some players and sets created I was born in 1966 so the 70s is when I truly became a baseball fan. The only reason I lean to the 60s is that I watched some of those decade stars as youngster. I'll just take care of the 70s first and see what happens but I like the thought of an 80s set also.
                          Originally posted by blackhawksfan4ever19
                          First off, if you do do 1 more for 23 might I suggest a 80's!! Era I grew up in.

                          As far as not buying Shows till they are cheap, now you sound like me. I'm STILL waiting for a little lower price. [emoji38]
                          Sent from my SM-G973W using Operation Sports mobile app
                          Pitching, defense and 2 out RBIs win a lot of ball games!

                          For classic sports highlights and livestream action, follow me on YouTube:
                          https://www.youtube.com/@greenmonster37ft/videos
                          Bluesky:
                          https://bsky.app/profile/bostonrob.bsky.social

                          Comment

                          • blackhawksfan4ever19
                            MVP
                            • May 2017
                            • 1512

                            #14
                            Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

                            Originally posted by bostongahden
                            Yeah it's also better to wait to buy games also because other creators already have some players and sets created I was born in 1966 so the 70s is when I truly became a baseball fan. The only reason I lean to the 60s is that I watched some of those decade stars as youngster. I'll just take care of the 70s first and see what happens but I like the thought of an 80s set also.

                            Sent from my SM-G973W using Operation Sports mobile app
                            Born in '68 here. Since I was young Don't remember too many things from the 70's but LOVE that you're "thinking" of an 80's set.
                            I am the way
                            I am the light
                            I am the dark inside the night.
                            I hear your hopes
                            I feel your dreams
                            And in the dark I hear your screams
                            Don't turn away, Just take my hand
                            I'll never leave, All I ask of you, Is Believe.

                            Believe

                            Savatage - RIP Chris Oliva - April 3, 1963 – October 17, 1993

                            Comment

                            • doncropper
                              MVP
                              • Jul 2002
                              • 1318

                              #15
                              Re: Classic Rosters - MLB 23

                              As you know, '60s is my sweet spot ............

                              Comment

                              Working...