Overrated and underrated players list

[TuffJuff]

Was going through the rosters today and I stumbled upon pitcher Kolby Allard for the Phillies. I was aware of him in his Texas days, but lost track of him recently. Dude is randomly a 79 overall on the game this year. Career 6.10 era. Best season was 4.96 5 years ago. Feel like I definitely need to change that. Shouldn’t even be a 70 overall. Figured I would make this thread for roster junkies to also list overrated or underrated players on the game

[TuffJuff]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

For the Twins I got 3 off the top of my head quick.
They have Louie Varland as a 59 overall RP. Should be a like 68-72 overall SP.

Funderburk as a 51 overall RP, making him one of the worst pitchers in the whole organization and unusable in games. He had a 2.36 era in the minors last year and an amazing 0.75 era in 12 major league innings. Starting the season in the majors this year. Dude has to be at least a low to mid 60’s overall.

Jordan Balazovic is a 70 overall starter. Dude is a failed top 100 prospect. Not even on the 40 man anymore and has been moved to the bullpen. Would think he should be like a 62 rp

[JaFFiTh]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

For the Twins I got 3 off the top of my head quick.
They have Louie Varland as a 59 overall RP. Should be a like 68-72 overall SP.

Funderburk as a 51 overall RP, making him one of the worst pitchers in the whole organization and unusable in games. He had a 2.36 era in the minors last year and an amazing 0.75 era in 12 major league innings. Starting the season in the majors this year. Dude has to be at least a low to mid 60’s overall.

Jordan Balazovic is a 70 overall starter. Dude is a failed top 100 prospect. Not even on the 40 man anymore and has been moved to the bullpen. Would think he should be like a 62 rp

Based on my own edits for the Twins, I’m at work so I don’t remember exactly but I actually have Varland as a SP at like 75 and Balazovic as a RP at like 60 or 62. His minor league numbers were crap too. I do weighted average of 3 years and as well as adjusted stats from A to AAA along with MLB. Haven’t done Funderbunk as he wasn’t in the MLB roster during my edits.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[TuffJuff]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Based on my own edits for the Twins, I’m at work so I don’t remember exactly but I actually have Varland as a SP at like 75 and Balazovic as a RP at like 60 or 62. His minor league numbers were crap too. I do weighted average of 3 years and as well as adjusted stats from A to AAA along with MLB. Haven’t done Funderbunk as he wasn’t in the MLB roster during my edits.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I definitely like to lean more conservative when doing ratings, but I would be totally fine with Varland at 75. Seems like we are on the same page. Makes it even more laughable that he is a 59 RP because coming out of the pen last year he was hitting 100 mph and had an era under 2.00. Small sample size, but still.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Dustin May - Dodgers - Pitcher
Not so much his Overall in general, but more specifically his Durability. 87? Overrated.
I'd say he can't be more than 67.Tommy John Surgery twice since 2021.
The most innings he's pitched in the last four years was in the two month long ''season'' of 2020.
And that was only 56 innings pitched in 2020. That's also his career season high outside of the minor leagues.

[blemons5]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Definitely agree about Allard being overrated. On the Braves, Pierce Johnson and Charlie Morton feel too low at 71 and 76, respectively

[ThrowBack]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Chris Paddack shouldn't be rated 83 with A potential. He looked promising back in 2019 but since then he has been terrible and he can't stay healthy.

[Madden08PCgmr]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Bullpen arms across the board.. *criminally* underrated.

Cited this when the ratings came out; there a number of unproven pitchers rated higher than George Kirby, after 2 seasons of Kirby proving he is a future ace.

Matt Brash is grossly underrated. When that slider is on, he is unhittable. The nastiest pitch I have seen this side of Mr Snappy. Backed it up with numbers last year, a remarkable strikeout rate for a reliever.

.. ran across Teoscar Hernandez on DD last night. I don't know what his roster rating is, but his DD card was laughably overrated.

[Therebelyell626]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Chris Paddack shouldn't be rated 83 with A potential. He looked promising back in 2019 but since then he has been terrible and he can't stay healthy.

He was considered one of the best pitching prospects in all of baseball when he was coming up. He was also pretty lights out when he came back towards the end of last year. But yeah, at 83/A a bit overrated. Was at one point dumped for Emilio Pagán and Brent Rooker before he became “Brent Rooker” lol

[djflock]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

He was considered one of the best pitching prospects in all of baseball when he was coming up. He was also pretty lights out when he came back towards the end of last year. But yeah, at 83/A a bit overrated. Was at one point dumped for Emilio Pagán and Brent Rooker before he became “Brent Rooker” lol

lol he pitched 5 innings across 2 games

[Therebelyell626]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

lol he pitched 5 innings across 2 games

Really??? I thought he pitched more than that. I might be getting him confused with someone else who came back from injury. Never the less, that makes the 83/A even more egregious lol.

I think he was an 80/B as recently as ‘22

[TuffJuff]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Really??? I thought he pitched more than that. I might be getting him confused with someone else who came back from injury. Never the less, that makes the 83/A even more egregious lol.

I think he was an 80/B as recently as ‘22

He pitched 5 innings in 2 games in September. Then he was rather impressive out of the pen in the playoffs, but yeah 83 may be a little too high until he can show he can stay healthy

[Incognito]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

The entire Oakland A's pitching staff. Giving any of their starting five high 70's rating is looking very generous right now.

[jacobcalvert3]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Another one is Orlando Arcia
His contact ratings seem too high for a guy who hit .264 last year


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[BrewCrew823]

Re: Overrated and underrated players list

Overall ratings aren’t always the thing to look at. I’ve followed many of the major roster editing projections over the years and they say the same. Each attribute has a different weight in contributing to the overall. Defense is more weighted for sure. Pitchers with good BB/9 increases the overall a lot.