MLB All-Time League

[FindingTim]

Quote: Originally Posted by CWSpalehoseCWS

IMO your White Sox roster needs some tweaking... Baines was a RF, Joe Jackson was a CF, and Minoso was a LF.

thanks for the heads up. Not sure how Minoso ended up in center, he only played 88 games there in his whole career.

speaking of Baines, he won the AL batting title in my first simulation. Who would have guessed? Regressed pretty hard in years 2 and 3 though...

Quote: Originally Posted by Rwings832

Can you explain how you are rating guys then? Are you taking their Overall Average as player and doing the ratings that way? I know a lot of guys on here would love to see what you got?

I imported players from a variety of places, so I can't claim to have a method for each players rating.
However, overall ratings are very important to me. I've made a lot of tweaks in that regard, and I'd say that the ratings in the roster linked in my first post can be disregarded. A lot of those players are rated too high or too low. For instance, Hal Trosky is definitely not a '98', as listed. He was a nice player, but '98' ratings are reserved for the elite of the elite. And speaking of 98's, Jeter's rating has been decreased, too. Iconic player, but not a 98 overall.

Generally, I think The Show's overall rating corresponds very well to the specific attributes. If a player's overall rating or potential rating seems off, I go in and edit the attributes that seem inflated or too low. To me, there is even a significant difference between '95' overall players and '94' overall players. It's a tier system.

Quote: Originally Posted by JonPaste

Just upload it, it's the off season would give us something fun to do.

The updated rosters are only in my franchise.
Imagine you wrote a novel you were very proud of, but the only thing available to the public was the mediocre first draft.

Once 2016 drops, I'll get this puppy out there as soon as possible.

[FindingTim]

UPDATE: Yesterday I went through all the teams and made everyone on the 25 man roster age 21. That way, you can play out 10+ seasons with these rosters.

I wish there was a way to turn off player progression... I edited a lot of "potential" ratings so hopefully that prevents everyone from becoming a 99 rating by year four. We'll see...

I couldn't edit ages of players on the SCEA roster. Guys like Johan Santana, Torii Hunter, Mark Buehrle, Cliff Lee, Carlos Beltran. It would be ideal to have all the players on the 25 man rosters the same age, but it's tough to omit these guys when their player models are so perfect. Still, if anyone has good CAP's of these guys, please let me know.

[JonPaste]

i dont want to read your novel I want to play with your rosters. But, just keep telling me how fun they are and all the fun your having with them.

[FindingTim]

Quote: Originally Posted by JonPaste

i dont want to read your novel I want to play with your rosters. But, just keep telling me how fun they are and all the fun your having with them.

I uploaded them as MLB ATL (base).

I warned you they are rough and unedited, so I don't want to hear you complaining. I've spent a lot of time trying to make a good roster set. Not digging your negativity.

But still, if you or anyone else have advice on how to improve lineups, rotations, player appearances, or player attributes, let me know. The goal is to make the rosters better. Also, if you have superior versions of specific historic players, let me know so we can swap them out for the 2016 release.

[JonPaste]

Thanks! I've never gripped about what I download when I put forth no effort. I appreciate you doing that I was just being a hard ***.

[FindingTim]

Quote: Originally Posted by Rwings832

Biebig2010 has a good All Time Roster set out as a base.

I checked out Biebig's roster out of curiosity. Holy hell is it good. For the most part, the player models destroy my roster. Also, there are great players I somehow overlooked, like HOF shortstop Bobby Wallace.

Sigh... I wish I'd known about this roster sooner. As of now, I'm considering abandoning my roster altogether-- loading Biebig's roster, then editing player ratings and ages.

My god... the amount of work that must have gone into making all those faces...

Quote: Originally Posted by JonPaste

Thanks! I've never gripped about what I download when I put forth no effort. I appreciate you doing that I was just being a hard ***.

Forget my rosters for now. A magician named Biebig2010 has created a superior product.

[doncropper]

Yep, Biebig2010 produces many exceptional roster sets. You should check out his other sets, somewhere around 5 or so for MLBTS 16, which each are superbly done. Those can keep one having fun for a very long time and cover almost any time period one maybe interested in revisiting!