List of Classic Seasons & Historical Specialty Rosters MLB The Show

[dowie]

Quote: Originally Posted by VDusen04

Novice question: When using historical rosters, how do you handle home stadiums? Do you just suck it up and run the '84 Giants at Oracle Park and Tigers at Comerica? Or do you make stand-in stadiums for them to use? If the latter, is there a limit to created stadiums and can they be assigned during franchise mode? As a whole, are there any other accommodations you guys make to make classic rosters feel as authentic as possible?

You are limited to 30 saves (stadiums).

Dowie

[Bonny]

Quote: Originally Posted by dowie

You are limited to 30 saves (stadiums). Dowie

I fill up all 30 available stadium save spots when applicable. The same with rebrands.

I have different PSN profiles set up for each era of projects that we create.

[ripcandlestickpark]

Came across this video earlier today. Haven't been able to download it myself yet, but this looks like a solid 1994 roster for MLB 23.

Per the video's description: "This roster is uploaded to the roster vault under the name Full 1994 Roster and under the gamertag mattlin352".

[CgyFlames]

Quote: Originally Posted by VDusen04

Novice question: When using historical rosters, how do you handle home stadiums? Do you just suck it up and run the '84 Giants at Oracle Park and Tigers at Comerica? Or do you make stand-in stadiums for them to use? If the latter, is there a limit to created stadiums and can they be assigned during franchise mode? As a whole, are there any other accommodations you guys make to make classic rosters feel as authentic as possible?

First of all, if you have a PS5 or XSX and are using historical rosters without era-accurate created stadiums, you’re not really playing historical baseball at all.

To answer another question, yes you can edit every team’s default home stadium in franchise mode.

And finally, you are limited to 30, but with smaller leagues and several stadiums in the base game already, I can’t imagine any single season requires more than 20 downloads.

[colepeyton]

Quote: Originally Posted by ripcandlestickpark

Came across this video earlier today. Haven't been able to download it myself yet, but this looks like a solid 1994 roster for MLB 23. Per the video's description: "This roster is uploaded to the roster vault under the name Full 1994 Roster and under the gamertag mattlin352".

outstanding work man!!!!! this looks incredible.

[Armor and Sword]

Quote: Originally Posted by CgyFlames

First of all, if you have a PS5 or XSX and are using historical rosters without era-accurate created stadiums, you’re not really playing historical baseball at all. To answer another question, yes you can edit every team’s default home stadium in franchise mode. And finally, you are limited to 30, but with smaller leagues and several stadiums in the base game already, I can’t imagine any single season requires more than 20 downloads.

That’s horse****.

Gameplay and atmosphere is supreme for me to enjoy historical rosters and for my money nothing plays better classic baseball than MLB 20. Coupled with 1980’s SOTS packs I have not had a better experience than on MLB 20 and all the 80’s rosters in that vault.

I think ATG is doing incredible work. Unfortunately for some of us we can’t get past the gameplay issues on 21/22/23.


That’s a subjective opinion just like the whole park comment.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[ripcandlestickpark]

There's a decent 2002 roster in the Vault as well: 2002 (Authentic/Detailed) by TheProdigy8267

It's a little rough around the edges with regards to things like faces and uniform numbers, but it's worth a look, IMO.

[TheBrew101]

Played a game with that 1994 roster. From what I can see it was very well done. Amazing what these roster creators can do.