Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

[saturn2187]

Player A: 34 GS (162 game season) Innings Per Start: 7 1/3
Player B: 27 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 7 1/3
Player C: 27 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 6 1/3
Player D: 26 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 6 1/3
Player E: 28 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 7

[redsox4evur]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

Player A: 34 GS (162 game season) Innings Per Start: 7 1/3
Player B: 27 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 7 1/3
Player C: 27 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 6 1/3
Player D: 26 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 6 1/3
Player E: 28 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 7

I think it has to be a toss up between B & D.

[cch99]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

I think it should be D.

[xNobleEaglex]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

I would vote B

[rjackson]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

In real life, it is D with only B being somewhat close because of the W-L record. If I had to vote myself, though, I'm not sure. C seems pretty unhittable.

[@legendm0de]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

Player D lol

I hate when baseball gets completely stripped down to what stats a guy has or had but 18 wins 0 losses speak loudly enough.

[saturn2187]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

Thanks for your input!

[shaneomac]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

If player A had a different W/L he would be the winner easy with 250 innings and a 2.27 ERA. That's pretty impressive. He should get strong consideration even with that W/L record.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

What's up with the 130 game seasons?
also Choice A is

Spoiler

King Felix 2010

[mlblover15]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

D is my vote as i have a guy in my franchise on my team that is currently 14-0 with a sub 2.00 era in late August...

[rjackson]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

Player D lol

I hate when baseball gets completely stripped down to what stats a guy has or had but 18 wins 0 losses speak loudly enough.

Agreed that statisticians are imperfect, still have a ways to go as far as baseball is concerned, etc BUT we cannot continue to ignore the proven facts that stats like a pitcher's W-L and RBI are meaningless...

[mmorg]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

If Pitcher C had more innings and maintained those rate stats he would be head and shoulders above everyone.

[decga]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

Player A: 34 GS (162 game season) Innings Per Start: 7 1/3
Player B: 27 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 7 1/3
Player C: 27 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 6 1/3
Player D: 26 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 6 1/3
Player E: 28 GS (130 game season) Innings Per Start: 7

If you could add Quality Starts to stat line I could make a decision.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

If you could add Quality Starts to stat line I could make a decision.

A had 30 QS, don't know about the rest but that's more than the others had starts.

[decga]

Re: Which Pitcher Deserves Cy?

A had 30 QS, don't know about the rest but that's more than the others had starts.

I am rolling with "A" base on 30 QS in 34 starts. He gave his team a chance to win just about 90% of his starts. He is just a bad luck loser with the 13-12 record.