MLB 15 The Show Player Ratings - Top Rated Players For Each Team

[BravoSir]

It was cool to see that I was close to the mark with some of my predictions with my team:

- RF Markakis 81
- CF Young Jr 77
- 1B Freeman 84
- LF Gomes (75-ish?)
- 3B CJohnson (76 likely)
- C Bethancourt 68
- 2B Callaspo (71-ish)
- SS Simmons 84

- C Pierzynski 73
- IF KJohnson (74-ish)
- OF Almonte (69-ish)
- IF Gosselin (76-ish)
- OF Perez (68-ish)

- Teheran 84
- Wood 82
- Miller 80
- Minor 81
- Stults 74

- Wandy 75
- Russell 76-ish
- Outman 70?
- Kohn 72?
- Grilli 77
- Vizcaino 60
- Kimbrel 96

[Ed21]

Judging a pitcher by how many wins he has is as useless as judging a hitters ability on how many RBI's he can drive in. Such a pointless stat when arguing a players case.

[garyjr33]

Quote: Originally Posted by jaysfan17

Max Scherzer is overrated as is Tanaka. Why does Delabar have a higher overall than Loup and Cecil? Thank god for OFSM

Tanaka is not overrated. He was dirty last year before his injury. Come on. Be reasonable. If it wasn't for his injury he would have played in the All-star game and been right there with Abreu for ROY. Scherzer has been one of the most consistent pitchers in the game for the past 3 years and eats innings. Not to mention the Cy Young in 2013.

[CubsWillRiseAgain]

Rizzo at 84 is very low. Castro at 80 is low.

They had Jon Lester, Cole Hamels at B potential, and Josh Harrison at an A. Thats absurd putting Harrison's potential over two bona fide aces.

[Trackball]

So all the Rockies pitchers suck this year (because that humidor can only do so much)?

Challenge accepted.

I'll put my RTTS pitcher there and prove them all wrong.

[ShowTyme15]

Quote: Originally Posted by seanjeezy

Lol why are you guys talking about wins and loses like those make any difference in the ratings? Over the last 3 seasons Scherzer has been the 3rd best starter in baseball. 10.46 K/9, 2.59 BB/9, 0.85 HR/9, and a .226 AVG against warrant a 94 or whatever he is.

First of all I wasn't using wins as it making up his rating (I already know win totals have nothing to do with ratings btw). The poster I replied to said Scherzer's was overrated so I just used his win total to justify that he isn't overrated.

Secondly, I really could give a rats a** about overall ratings and how they are calculated in all honesty.

[eric7064]

Quote: Originally Posted by CubsWillRiseAgain

Rizzo at 84 is very low. Castro at 80 is low. They had Jon Lester, Cole Hamels at B potential, and Josh Harrison at an A. Thats absurd putting Harrison's potential over two bona fide aces.

I'm a Cubs fan. I think Rizzo is fine when you look at the 1B above him. Plus he's an A he will progress well over a franchise. I agree on Castro. 3x all star an 80?! Cmon. But comparing a 31 yr old established pitcher potential to a young up and coming All-Star? Lester is 30 he won't rise much in overall. Potential does not mean much at his age.

[mikeq672]

The ratings are pretty terrible.