As a 2K player myself, I actually disagree.
I'm okay with the off-court stuff as it is right now (2K16's was far worse). It's when it gets ON the court that's a problem...this year was a serious misstep, what with all the psychic steals, reaching into the passing lane the INSTANT you hit the pass button...But I'm getting off on a tangent here.
My point is, even though baseball is not my real-world sport of choice, I do consider The Show a better baseball game than 2K is a basketball game. And I buy the game because of that (and not Madden, though they can still fix their own issues).