Top 10 Players at Each Position in MLB The Show 17

[Burge88]

Donaldson as the top 3rd baseman?
I'd take Bryant, Arenado, or machado over him any day. Heck, maybe even Beltre

[Jaysguy44]

Quote: Originally Posted by Burge88

Donaldson as the top 3rd baseman? I'd take Bryant, Arenado, or machado over him any day. Heck, maybe even Beltre

Donaldson will have those guys for breakfast..he's a viking! he rapes and pillage pitchers.

[Steven78]

Quote: Originally Posted by Burge88

Donaldson as the top 3rd baseman? I'd take Bryant, Arenado, or machado over him any day. Heck, maybe even Beltre

Bryant has the same rating and Arenado and Machado are just 1 point behind.

[eric7064]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jaysguy44

Dude, when Arenado wins an MVP then we can talk.

He should have one, if not 2. All around I would take Arenado over Donaldson every day of the week. Arenado is so underated among baseball people.

[Jaysguy44]

Quote: Originally Posted by eric7064

He should have one, if not 2. All around I would take Arenado over Donaldson every day of the week. Arenado is so underated among baseball people.

Dude calm down, Arenado had 2 good seasons...when he puts together a couple more then you can say he's awesome until then Donaldson is the man!.

[ZoltanZ]

I like Arenado and he was pretty much my 3B on my DD team for most of the time i played. He gets dinged because he has a relatively short track record and he plays in Colorado 81 games a year. If his stats are even close to another 3B he is going to get knocked down a peg because of that.

[Dolenz]

Ah, time for the yearly ritual of complaints about ratings

*Insert Player Name* from the *insert favorite team* should be rated higher. What were they thinking?

No way *Insert name highly ranked Player* is better than *Insert name of lower ranked player*.

Folks need to remember a couple of things

1. The rating is based on a 3 year average not just last year (50%/25%/25% roughly)
2. It is not subjective. You may not agree with the rating methodolgy but it is a computation that is made and not the devs subjective opinions.

[LetMeSlytherinU]

Where is Rick Porcello? Seriously?