UFC 106: Forrest vs Tito

[DTX3]

Quote:

UFC 106 November 21st 2009 Mandalay Bay Events Center Announced fights: Heavyweight Championship bout: Brock Lesnar (c) vs. Shane Carwin Light Heavyweight bout: Mark Coleman vs. Tito Ortiz Welterweight bout: Jon Fitch vs. Ricardo Almeida Lightweight bout: Kenny Florian vs. Clay Guida Welterweight bout: Karo Parisyan vs. Dustin Hazelett

.

[aholbert32]

Cain kind of gets screwed here. Who does he face now? Mir and Kongo are scheduled for later this year. CroCop is booked. Maybe he fights Herring now.

Cain went from being 1 fight away from a title shot to probably 2 or 3. Especially if Couture wins next week.

[MC Fatigue]

Makes sense to me. Carwin vs V. never made sense to me in the first place; if the guy couldn't finish a guy like Kongo on the ground, and was getting demolishing standing with him - what could he possibly have done with Carwin? I didn't really see the point, since Cain wasn't really all that good looking against Kongo.

[DTX3]

Quote: Originally Posted by aholbert32

Cain kind of gets screwed here. Who does he face now? Mir and Kongo are scheduled for later this year. CroCop is booked. Maybe he fights Herring now. Cain went from being 1 fight away from a title shot to probably 2 or 3. Especially if Couture wins next week.

I still think Cain is 1 win away from a title shot. No way does Couture deserve a title shot with a win against Nog.

[Wet Bandit]

Quote: Originally Posted by Timmay

Makes sense to me. Carwin vs V. never made sense to me in the first place; if the guy couldn't finish a guy like Kongo on the ground, and was getting demolishing standing with him - what could he possibly have done with Carwin? I didn't really see the point, since Cain wasn't really all that good looking against Kongo.

And Carwin looked good against Gonzaga? He got rocked right away, got taken down and put on his back, and won the fight by connecting against a guy with a notoriously suspect chin.

I'm not saying Cain's last fight was much better, but at least he showed something during that fight. He showed he has an incredible chin, considering he took 3 or 4 clean shots from a powerful striker and didn't really get phased. And he showed his excellent wrestling. Granted, it's not tough to out-wrestle Kongo, but he didn't simply out-wrestle him, he destroyed him on the ground. And sure Cain didn't finish him, but if it wasn't obvious already, Lesnar/Herring should have showed us that it's tough to finish a tough guy that's determined to turtle up.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think Cain walks through Carwin or anything. I just don't understand how the Carwin mystique has taken off these past couple months. People have been acting like Cain was merely a speedbump for him. But what's Carwin got for Cain? He's got power in his striking, but more power than Kongo? If Cain could eat all of Kongo's power directly on his chin, what would Carwin have done?

And Carwin's got about 15 pounds on Cain, but Cain was a 2-time All-American at Arizona State, a great Division 1 wrestling school. Carwin wrestled at freaking Western State College.

I think that fight would still have been very much of a toss-up. There was a good chance Carwin could have out-struck Cain or used his size to out-wrestle him, but I think there's also a good chance Cain could have caught Carwin with some of his own power (after all, Gonzaga rocked Carwin with punches) or used his better technical wrestling to negate Carwin's size advantage and out-wrestled him.

[aholbert32]

Quote: Originally Posted by DTX3

I still think Cain is 1 win away from a title shot. No way does Couture deserve a title shot with a win against Nog.

Whats a bigger PPV draw? Coulture v. Lesner or Cain vs Lesner?

[Wet Bandit]

Quote: Originally Posted by DTX3

I still think Cain is 1 win away from a title shot. No way does Couture deserve a title shot with a win against Nog.

I think it depends on how well Couture does. If he walks through Big Nog, I think it's totally justified giving Couture a title shot, considering he did relatively well against Lesnar in their first fight and he's still a very good draw who's only got a couple opportunities for big fights left in him.

But I doubt that Couture walks through Big Nog, so yeah, Cain's probably still one fight away from a title shot. And instead of having to beat Carwin for it, now he's only gotta beat someone like Heath Herring for it.

At worst, he's two fights away from a title fight, but I don't think that's any different than it was before. If Couture showed well against Big Nog, I think he would have gotten a title shot before the winner of Cain/Carwin would have.

[DTX3]

Quote: Originally Posted by aholbert32

Whats a bigger PPV draw? Coulture v. Lesner or Cain vs Lesner?

There's no doubt that Couture vs Lensar is a bigger draw, but that's no reason to give Randy the title shot when you clearly have a fighter in Cain who deserves it more(with a win).

Quote: Originally Posted by Wet Bandit

I think it depends on how well Couture does. If he walks through Big Nog, I think it's totally justified giving Couture a title shot, considering he did relatively well against Lesnar in their first fight and he's still a very good draw who's only got a couple opportunities for big fights left in him. But I doubt that Couture walks through Big Nog, so yeah, Cain's probably still one fight away from a title shot. And instead of having to beat Carwin for it, now he's only gotta beat someone like Heath Herring for it. At worst, he's two fights away from a title fight, but I don't think that's any different than it was before. If Couture showed well against Big Nog, I think he would have gotten a title shot before the winner of Cain/Carwin would have.

See, even if Randy walks through Nog I still don't think he deserves a shot(just yet), just my opinion. I would like to see the winner of this fight take on Cain(if he wins his next fight) to determine the #1 contender. I don't see that happening though. Also, just imo, I don't see Randy walking through Big Nog next week.

Now that I think of it, the HW division isn't all that great in the UFC.