I tried part of V. 2, mostly the pitching stuff for one game. Then adjusted some of the sliders for the second game.
In details, here's what I changed in game 1 (everything as per V. 2 of Jistic's slider).
- Fielding: Assisted (I'm not that bad on Manual, but every 5 game I will miss a ball by inch thinking I was in front of it and it frustrates me so much I had to go to assisted fielding.)
- Strike Zone: Off
- Hot/Cold Zones: Fade
- Pitch Cursor: Fade
- Hitters Eye: On
- Catch Circle Assist: Off
- Variable Strike Zone, 'Stuff', and Blown Calls: On
- Vibration: Off (This is a MUST for pitching if you want to give up walks)
- User pitch meter difficulty : 37
- CPU pitcher ball rate : 17
- User and CPU Pitching fatigue : -38 & 6
- User and CPU Pitch Control : -45 & -20
I did not touch any basic (contact, power) batting sliders since I didn't have any issues with those. I had a three-HR the other day with Vlad and the hits are pretty realistic.
- User and CPU Foul Ball Freq. : 50
- CPU Swing Frequency : -33
I did not touch the fielder's speed, since I play on Assisted for fielding and I'm pretty pleased with how it's going.
- User and CPU Throw Accuracy : -15 & -23
- User and CPU Catch Error : -40 (changed User same as CPU, since I'm on Assisted, not sure I had to)
- CPU Catch Effort : -10
- I forgot to change CPU runner agression to (-10), but I'll do it. Didn't have any problem with it though for my 2 games.
- CPU steal rate : 16
I did not change the other steal sliders, since I was okay with them too. Gotta give credit to MVP they gave us some of the best default settings I've seen in any sports game.
Gotta warn the purists, here I did a fantasy draft with the Anaheim Angels (of Los Angeles?!?!) since my Expos are not anymore. So I have an excellent team, chose 7th. Got Vlad first, but was injured for the season in a previous game trying to break up a DP, sliding at second. So my lineup looks a little like this from memory.
1. CF T. Hunter
2. SS C. Izturis
3. LF L. Ford
4. 3B A. Beltre
5. 1B T. Martinez
6. 2B ?. Ginter
7. DH D. Roberts
8. RF J. Werth
9. C B. Schneider
First game I visit Seattle, L. Hernandez (ANA) vs C. Zambrano
Seattle's lineup is pretty average, big players are Konerko and ???don't remember.
Anyway, very fun game
Won 2-0, Beltre hit a 2-run HR in the first and Livan allowed only three hits. I got nine hits and an error by the SS going back to catch a scratcher who dropped it. I had only one K on the mound and 6 at bats. I'm not really a K pitcher most of the time.
Comments about the sliders : the pitching counts were great, an average of at least of approximately 4 pitches/AB, some short AB, some average and a couple of long battles. A great mix overall, so that objective was reached.
At bat, since I used to play with strike zone on, I was surprised to see I had a better eye without it. It seems it caused more of an a view obstruction than anything. I still check swing every three balls thrown at me, although it's much easier in this version to hold it back than it was last year. So it's not too much of a problem. The more I play, I should get better at it.
Anyway the only major gripe I had the settings was the pitcher's fatigue on my part. Even with a pitch count around 100-110+, Livan completed the game at 53%. Although you have to take in consideration that he has 99 stamina. I also found the meter still a little easy even at the end of the game.
So here's the modification I made for my second game.
- User pitch meter difficulty : -45
- User pitcher fatigue : -6
- CPU pitcher fatigue : 11
I faced Detroit this with Manny Ramirez, Ron Belliard and that pretty much it. The rest were average to bad.
I had Ismael Valdes on the mound facing Doug Davis for the felines.
I won 2-1. Tigers opened the scoring in the top of the 3rd when RBI double by Belliard. I answered back bottom of the 4th with a 2-run double by Izturis.
Valdes pitched 7.0 innings, around 100 pitches, 7 Ks (I was on fire and the ump was generous), but most interestingly when I took him out he was at 37% of energy and the pitching control was just how I thought it should be.
I faced one hitter in the 7th, gave a single and took him out seeing it was getting real tough to pitch where I wanted. The fatigue was also perfect for my relievers. Got 3 more Ks from my relievers (Timlin, Romero and Percival). I struck out 5 times at bat, first time ever I double the opposition in Ks (and probably last).
So, I'll continue with those sliders and maybe boost the hitting both for user and CPU a tiny bit and I should be good. I'll also switch the pitch cursor from fade to off, shouldn't be too much of a problem. I may tweak a little more, but for now it looks pretty good.

Thanks Jistic for the good base. I'll make sure to check the thread again in a couple of days, to see the progression of everybody with it, but I'm confident they could work in the long run.
Edit : As for the CPU steals, in 2 games the CPU didn't have much chance to try it, so I don't know, but I'll monitor it and get to you.