what do you mean was he really that good? so you are saying Melo at some point in his career was better than prime T-Mac? are you serious? Melo has never been that good to deserve the cards 2k has given him. He may have finished 6th in MVP race once but T-Mac finished 4th in a TIGHT race where you had KG, Shaq, Kobe all of who were on better teams. Timmy won it because he was the best player on the best team in the league, but nobody did what T-Mac did statistically that year even pushing them to the playoffs in a year Grant Hill barely played. T-Mac probably never gets the credit he truly deserves because he always played on garbage teams. He rarely was on the court with Grant Hill or Yao. You think Dirk MVP season was better? Only because Dallas won almost 70 games.
The guy never played on a team that had any good players that werent injured but he was the best offensive force in the league for two years. everyone always points to the game where Kobe scored 24 in the 4th quarter to be the Magic. They also say he shut down T-Mac in the 4th quarter. I remember that team having Shaq, Horace Grant, Glove, Mailman, Fox, Fisher, etc. Name me one player off the top of your head that was on that Orlando team that year.
Better than any version of Melo, Love, Kyrie, Dirk, Brow, all of who have higher rated cards than him. Certainly better than any version of PG13 or Butler. The only other modern player that probably gets shortchanged as much in the game is Wade, and he was only given a great card because of being ASG MVP.
His numbers were similar to MJ MVP card except for the FG%, but T-Mac had zero help.
32ppg, 6.5rpg, 5.5apg. Yes, he was THAT good.