Recommended Videos

Collapse

Illegal Defense

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #1
    xCoachDx
    MVP
    • Aug 2015
    • 1304

    Illegal Defense


    Is this not actually in the game in the Eras Mode? Playing both in the Jordan Era as well as the Modern Era with “Remove Zone Defense” and it still seems to be the modern Defensive 3 Seconds rule and nothing else. If it’s there, I haven’t been able to trigger it yet unless I’m standing in the paint.

    Really disappointing if so. Something I was most looking forward to.
  • #2
    Bremser_Rules
    Pro
    • Aug 2004
    • 583

    Re: Illegal Defense


    Re: Illegal Defense

    Yeah I haven't seen any evidence of it either. Disappointing.
    They call me Mr. Thread Cooler

    Comment

    • #3
      jk31
      MVP
      • Sep 2014
      • 2670

      Re: Illegal Defense


      Re: Illegal Defense

      thats 2k. Such "small" things get overlooked very often. the New take Foul rule is also Not In the game.

      Comment

      • #4
        AIRJ23
        MVP
        • Apr 2021
        • 2804

        Re: Illegal Defense


        Re: Illegal Defense

        Originally posted by jk31
        thats 2k. Such "small" things get overlooked very often. the New take Foul rule is also Not In the game.
        That rule is definitely in the game. I get techs all the time for trying to swipe the ball after cpu grabs a defensive rebound.

        Comment

        • #5
          NYJin2011tm
          MVP
          • Oct 2011
          • 2770

          Re: Illegal Defense


          Re: Illegal Defense

          Yea take foul is def in the game, if you play Modern era.

          Comment

          • #6
            xCoachDx
            MVP
            • Aug 2015
            • 1304

            Re: Illegal Defense


            Re: Illegal Defense

            Originally posted by Bremser_Rules
            Yeah I haven't seen any evidence of it either. Disappointing.

            That makes me want no part of this game. I’ve been wanting this implemented for years and thought we finally had it. Typical 2K.

            Comment

            • #7
              The 24th Letter
              ERA
              • Oct 2007
              • 39373

              Re: Illegal Defense


              Re: Illegal Defense

              Entirely too dramatic in here

              There’s a “Little Things” thread full of things they got right for eras

              Hopefully this is something they can add as the mode progresses

              Comment

              • #8
                xCoachDx
                MVP
                • Aug 2015
                • 1304

                Re: Illegal Defense


                Re: Illegal Defense

                Originally posted by The 24th Letter
                Entirely too dramatic in here

                There’s a “Little Things” thread full of things they got right for eras

                Hopefully this is something they can add as the mode progresses

                That’s your opinion.

                For me, as I said before, that’s the number one thing I’ve wanted in MyNBA for years is the ability to revert to old rule sets. With all of the comparisons of players from different eras, I’ve always said that the differentials in the rules make it impossible to compare. We had a chance to have that. It’s something they hyped up and apparently did not deliver on. What’s the point of having 90s basketball if everyone can just sag off of non shooters? It’s very unrealistic.

                I’m glad those “little things” are good enough for you. I really am. But the failure to implement that correctly is a game killer. You can’t go back and play old school basketball. You can only bring old school to the modern era. That’s not something I had any interest in doing.

                So no, to me, that’s not being too dramatic.

                Comment

                • #9
                  The 24th Letter
                  ERA
                  • Oct 2007
                  • 39373

                  Re: Illegal Defense


                  Re: Illegal Defense

                  Originally posted by xCoachDx
                  That’s your opinion.

                  For me, as I said before, that’s the number one thing I’ve wanted in MyNBA for years is the ability to revert to old rule sets. With all of the comparisons of players from different eras, I’ve always said that the differentials in the rules make it impossible to compare. We had a chance to have that. It’s something they hyped up and apparently did not deliver on. What’s the point of having 90s basketball if everyone can just sag off of non shooters? It’s very unrealistic.

                  I’m glad those “little things” are good enough for you. I really am. But the failure to implement that correctly is a game killer. You can’t go back and play old school basketball. You can only bring old school to the modern era. That’s not something I had any interest in doing.

                  So no, to me, that’s not being too dramatic.

                  Sorry illegal defense not being in the game is a game killer for you

                  Good luck next year


                  Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    jk31
                    MVP
                    • Sep 2014
                    • 2670

                    Re: Illegal Defense


                    Re: Illegal Defense

                    Originally posted by NYJin2011tm
                    Yea take foul is def in the game, if you play Modern era.

                    alright then it seems like this again is another thing that is missing on old gen.....i hope 2k lets me buy the current game version of the game next year on pc...

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      NYJin2011tm
                      MVP
                      • Oct 2011
                      • 2770

                      Re: Illegal Defense


                      Re: Illegal Defense

                      Originally posted by jk31
                      alright then it seems like this again is another thing that is missing on old gen.....i hope 2k lets me buy the current game version of the game next year on pc...
                      I do too! Would love to have the Eras on my Steam Deck. I too was disappointed PC wasn’t next gen. What would totally rock would be PC next gen with cross saves with PS5 and/or Series X/S.

                      Comment

                      Working...