Do you agree that nba 2k has the best commentary?

[iam31yearsold]

Live has only authentic audio. As in when you play in MSG, the crowd noise is the actual crowd from a Knicks game at MSG.

That's next level.

Sent from my XT1528 using Tapatalk

[BBallcoach]

Quote: Originally Posted by basehead617

Who wouldn't be atrocious? Mark Jackson and Jeff Van Gundy were atrocious in Live. Kerr was good but is coaching. Pickings getting slim..

If they could get Harlan's real life TV partner in Reggie Miller it would be fine. But Kellog and Anthony don't do NBA coverage nationally. So it's weird to have College guys doing the NBA. Hell get Chris Webber or Brent Barry any of the other TNT guys with Harlan. Since they are getting closer, they just need to go all TNT.

[SonicMage]

Quote: Originally Posted by BBallcoach

If they could get Harlan's real life TV partner in Reggie Miller it would be fine. But Kellog and Anthony don't do NBA coverage nationally. So it's weird to have College guys doing the NBA. Hell get Chris Webber or Brent Barry any of the other TNT guys with Harlan. Since they are getting closer, they just need to go all TNT.

I think its pretty obvious right now that Reggie, Barkley, and C-Webb want nothing to do with NBA 2K.

[Armor and Sword]

2K16 is the best network style presentation I have ever experienced.

[iam31yearsold]

MLB 15 has best presentation...and well...pretty much best everything.

But since it's only on PS4, and baseball isn't a sport that is as popular as NBA, NFL, and FIFA...it rarely gets the shine it deserves.

Crowd, presentation, commentary, pre and post game intros, and highlight reel that works every time, all tops.

Sent from my XT1528 using Tapatalk

[Armor and Sword]

Quote: Originally Posted by iam31yearsold

MLB 15 has best presentation...and well...pretty much best everything. But since it's only on PS4, and baseball isn't a sport that is as popular as NBA, NFL, and FIFA...it rarely gets the shine it deserves. Crowd, presentation, commentary, pre and post game intros, and highlight reel that works every time, all tops. Sent from my XT1528 using Tapatalk

I really like MLB 15's presentation as well.....but 2K16 has it down. It is far more dynamic. And the network (TNT) style presentation is now second to none IMO. Player interviews between quarters. Pre, halftime and post game shows. Post season presentation, draft lottery presentation, draft presentation.

It's amazing IMO.

MLB 15 needs to take some cues from 2K16 and take it to the next level.

[iam31yearsold]

I feel you. For sure, everyone needs to take it to the next level but...the presentation style is almost identical to MLBTV.

They have pre game intros with players warming up, talking to old teammates and laughing with them, signing autographs and throwing the ball into the stands. Postgame interviews with shaving cream in the face of rookies and Gatorade dumps. If you wait too long between pitches, umpires start talking to players, they walk around, general baseball ambience action.

All Star games change cities every year with logos that say that year.

This stuff have been in there since MLB 07 on the PS2. It has expanded, but that idea has been in the game for 6+ years.

It has full on different Post Season presentations with different music, banners, and an on field graphic that displays the series year all the way up to 2030. Player intros up the baseline.

MLBs draft is weak, but its not a spectacle like the NBA is in real life.

The 2k interviews are innovative, but they repeat often and are like 4 or 5 sentences.

This post isn't about 2k commentary at all...haha...but in my opinion, 2k built most of these ideas off of MLB.
Sent from my XT1528 using Tapatalk

[iam31yearsold]

Shaq, Ernie, and Kenny though, top notch. It repeats, but they are long and engaging. I love those intros.

Sent from my XT1528 using Tapatalk