Fouls

[davel]

Just wondering how the fouls are?

Is there a realistic amount?
Is there a variety of fouls?


This is a make or break if I buy the game.

[penny80]

Re: Fouls

No, there aren't good news
as every year, there is a HUGE lack of non-shooting fouls

At the moment i can't see enough variety of fouls, shooting fouls are good (but not from long distance, only diving to the basket) some reaching and then STOP, let see w slider/roster settings what can we do, but i lost the hope after ten years on this problem

-sliders have no effect
-we need more diving, more contact, more hustle
-referees have to call much


we need 21 avg fouls per team on 48 min game, about 13/15 shooting fouls, 7/8 non-shooting.
I'm tired also to write on this problem

many kids here, will read and not worry about this problem, because many people play in arcade style without paying much attention to the simulation of the game

For us who are looking for realism, and therefore the right number of fouls over 12 minutes a quarter, unfortunately we are a little disappointed

BTW this is the BEST 2k ever released, no doubt on this

[devroyce]

Re: Fouls

No, there aren't good news
as every year, there is a HUGE lack of non-shooting fouls

At the moment i can't see enough variety of fouls, shooting fouls are good (but not from long distance, only diving to the basket) some reaching and then STOP, let see w slider/roster settings what can we do, but i lost the hope after ten years on this problem

-sliders have no effect
-we need more diving, more contact, more hustle
-referees have to call much


we need 21 avg fouls per team on 48 min game, about 13/15 shooting fouls, 7/8 non-shooting.
I'm tired also to write on this problem

many kids here, will read and not worry about this problem, because many people play in arcade style without paying much attention to the simulation of the game

For us who are looking for realism, and therefore the right number of fouls over 12 minutes a quarter, unfortunately we are a little disappointed

BTW this is the BEST 2k ever released, no doubt on this

@penny80 has spoken lol. Hey man I don't have the game yet but do they at least have blocking fouls now? I remember 2K18 had at least some blocking fouls, but no reaching fouls...then the reverse happened with 2K19...reaching fouls only and no blocking fouls. What about off-ball fouls...see any? And ahhh...the everlasting non-existent jumpshot fouls always existed. "Yawn"...Somebody tag my name & wake me up if you see various fouls at some point. In the meantime, maybe I will buy the game soon...maybe.

[penny80]

Re: Fouls

@penny80 has spoken lol. Hey man I don't have the game yet but do they at least have blocking fouls now? I remember 2K18 had at least some blocking fouls, but no reaching fouls...then the reverse happened with 2K19...reaching fouls only and no blocking fouls. What about off-ball fouls...see any? And ahhh...the everlasting non-existent jumpshot fouls always existed. "Yawn"...Somebody tag my name & wake me up if you see various fouls at some point. In the meantime, maybe I will buy the game soon...maybe.

no blocking fouls, no charge, no fouls on shooting from long range, no over the back


@devroyce

i'm so so sad!

[penny80]

Re: Fouls

@devroyce and all
important!!!

i just play a game in HOF diff, there are MORE MORE MORE contacts, more fouls call

i'm really happy on this, i play just a quarter but it is day and night
i hope that w the slider and roster settings this year we FINALLY have a good result

[antdoggydogg]

Re: Fouls

I've been getting a realistic NUMBER of them, for both teams. About 20 per team over 48 minutes. But it might not be the variety that you are probably looking for. I didn't see any blocking calls or charges.

This is all with default sliders by the way. Haven't tried adjusting anything yet.

[antdoggydogg]

Re: Fouls

@devroyce and all
important!!!

i just play a game in HOF diff, there are MORE MORE MORE contacts, more fouls call

i'm really happy on this, i play just a quarter but it is day and night
i hope that w the slider and roster settings this year we FINALLY have a good result

Maybe we should copy over some of the HOF sliders to get these results in All-Star

[penny80]

Re: Fouls

I've been getting a realistic NUMBER of them, for both teams. About 20 per team over 48 minutes. But it might not be the variety that you are probably looking for. I didn't see any blocking calls or charges.

This is all with default sliders by the way. Haven't tried adjusting anything yet.

Ok this is already a good point to start
as vanilla it is the best version ever

[devroyce]

Re: Fouls

@devroyce and all
important!!!

i just play a game in HOF diff, there are MORE MORE MORE contacts, more fouls call

i'm really happy on this, i play just a quarter but it is day and night
i hope that w the slider and roster settings this year we FINALLY have a good result

1. Thanks for clarifying this for all.

I've been getting a realistic NUMBER of them, for both teams. About 20 per team over 48 minutes. But it might not be the variety that you are probably looking for. I didn't see any blocking calls or charges.

This is all with default sliders by the way. Haven't tried adjusting anything yet.

2. Still great news that you are seeing this on default without increasing any foul slider...thanks for the confirmation also.

Maybe we should copy over some of the HOF sliders to get these results in All-Star

3. Bingo!

Ok this is already a good point to start
as vanilla it is the best version ever

4. hmmm...So really this 2K20 is that great...all we would need is the foul variety then...And I will add something outside of fouls - I hope you guys are not seeing players steal/intercept passes with one hand all game long anymore/but instead see more realistic tips/deflections!

... can't wait to buy the game hearing some of the news you guys are bringing.

[CaseIH]

Re: Fouls

Just wondering how the fouls are?

Is there a realistic amount?
Is there a variety of fouls?


This is a make or break if I buy the game.

Nope, fouls are basically still broken, if your wanting to see charges and shooting fouls on 3pt attempts get called, that is. Also the CPU still doesnt manage timeouts very good either. I beat the Wizards by 43 points, on 12 minute qtrs a little bit ago and the Wizards called 1 timeout the entire game My guess is the CPU doesnt manage player fouls trouble any better either this yr. Its seems these issues, which really hurt the game for people who want a simulation of the NBA,isnt important enough for the devs to fix.



Outside of those issues, the game looks amazing, and its smoother than any previous NBA2k game, that I can remember. Its a shame the wont fix these few major issues for the hardcore basketball fans, who play this game, because otherwise its a great game.

[penny80]

Re: Fouls

But it must be admitted, this year the product is super good!

All in all at the end of the race you will be able to get the right number of fouls, they will not be so various that we care, but the reaching fouls manage to cover the lack of blocking and therefore at the end of the race you can get the right number of fouls per team

I have to admit I was wrong initially, I saw videos made on PRO difficulties and they were boring, everything changes at HOF

Congratz 2k, we are on the right road

[jakalfc]

Re: Fouls

But it must be admitted, this year the product is super good!



All in all at the end of the race you will be able to get the right number of fouls, they will not be so various that we care, but the reaching fouls manage to cover the lack of blocking and therefore at the end of the race you can get the right number of fouls per team



I have to admit I was wrong initially, I saw videos made on PRO difficulties and they were boring, everything changes at HOF



Congratz 2k, we are on the right road

You used Hall of fame by default or you changed something

Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

[devroyce]

Re: Fouls

You used Hall of fame by default or you changed something

Inviato dal mio ANE-LX1 utilizzando Tapatalk

https://forums.operationsports.com/f...p?p=2049896780

I will let him say it...but @penny80 told me that he did not change a thing on HOF Default, in that thread.

[CaseIH]

Re: Fouls

But it must be admitted, this year the product is super good!

All in all at the end of the race you will be able to get the right number of fouls, they will not be so various that we care, but the reaching fouls manage to cover the lack of blocking and therefore at the end of the race you can get the right number of fouls per team

I have to admit I was wrong initially, I saw videos made on PRO difficulties and they were boring, everything changes at HOF

Congratz 2k, we are on the right road

Does it take playing on HOF to see enough fouls being called? I sure hope not, because my reaction time, just isnt what it use to be, so aint no way I can play HOF, Im not sure without major editing that I can even play superstar, LOL.

[twinlove9301]

Re: Fouls

I very rarely post but for myleague players and slider makers, this could be awesome. When starting a myleague under setup(simulation category), you can change how often certain things happen in a game. Ex.Fouls shots turnovers and more. Also by whom. Ex. Set the sliders for players who foul a lot to foul more than others. This along with regular sliders can get it very real