Local v. Cloud Saved Data Loop Error

[NateDogPack12]

A message pops up asking "Which one do you want to use? The saved data we have in the cloud is different from the data we have on this Xbox".

Then I have 3 options (1) This console, (2) Xbox Live and (3) Cancel.

Seems simple enough, I chose the current data on the console, but the same message pops back up. After trying a couple times I figured out that this message keeps popping up no matter what I press, even cancwl. I'm stuck in a loop that I can't get out of. I tried force quitting the game, restarting the Xbox, and anything else I could think of, but the same message keeps coming up.

Normally I would just delete the game and re-install, but I created a bunch of custom draft classes/content I don't want to lose and I’m pretty sure they’re saved locally.

So, is this an Xbox Live issue or a game issue? Any way I can resolve this without losing my data? Thanks for any help.