The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[chiefs314]

This trade would never happen in real life but this is a video game

sixers get
john wall
nick young
2nd rd pick

wizards get
evan turner
jrue holiday
1st rd pick

is this a fair trade?

[thaprodigyisback]

Quote: Originally Posted by chiefs314

This trade would never happen in real life but this is a video game sixers get john wall nick young 2nd rd pick wizards get evan turner jrue holiday 1st rd pick is this a fair trade?

Hell Yea


Sent from my T-Mobile G1 using Tapatalk

[thedukejr]

I have been thinking about trading Bynum. I used the trade finder and found some interesting trades for him. I would like to know if any of them are realistic and which one is the better deal.

bynum & '12 1st rd
for
al jefferson

bynum & blake
for
amar'e & roger mason

bynum & '12 2nd rd
for
wesley johnson & '11 1st rd

[thedukejr]

Quote: Originally Posted by chiefs314

This trade would never happen in real life but this is a video game sixers get john wall nick young 2nd rd pick wizards get evan turner jrue holiday 1st rd pick is this a fair trade?

this trade seems pretty fair since the 1st round pick might end up being a lottery pick.

[ffaacc03]

Quote: Originally Posted by thedukejr

I have been thinking about trading Bynum. I used the trade finder and found some interesting trades for him. I would like to know if any of them are realistic and which one is the better deal. bynum & '12 1st rd for al jefferson bynum & blake for amar'e & roger mason bynum & '12 2nd rd for wesley johnson & '11 1st rd

The first two are long, looong shots (extremly improbable for not saying impossible) ... the last one is more probable but I dont like it as LA has too many good wings and MIN has too many bigs ... I think you can find a better deal elsewhere.

[thaprodigyisback]

Quote: Originally Posted by thedukejr

I have been thinking about trading Bynum. I used the trade finder and found some interesting trades for him. I would like to know if any of them are realistic and which one is the better deal. bynum & '12 1st rd for al jefferson bynum & blake for amar'e & roger mason bynum & '12 2nd rd for wesley johnson & '11 1st rd

Personally I think you should disregard the Knicks offer

[thedukejr]

Quote: Originally Posted by ffaacc03

The first two are long, looong shots (extremly improbable for not saying impossible) ... the last one is more probable but I dont like it as LA has too many good wings and MIN has too many bigs ... I think you can find a better deal elsewhere.

i thought those weren't too realistic. i was also offered josh smith for bynum. what do you think about that trade?

[ffaacc03]

Quote: Originally Posted by thedukejr

i thought those weren't too realistic. i was also offered josh smith for bynum. what do you think about that trade?

I like it for ATL a lot, not sure about LA ... while Smith is a good defensive player and has some length, he isnt the type of big you would need to replace Bynum ... then again, you could do a another trade further on or sign a FA to address that and round the first one ... see what big does the combo of Ratliff & Smith & Caracter can net you.