Over- /underrated players in the game?

[BIGNUNT]

My choice

Underrated - Dirk, Krstic and J.J. Reddick
Overrated - Wall and Kaman

[Boge]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

I'm not really going to say who I think is overrated or underrated since I haven't scoped out the ratings that much, but I will say that there are a number of players in this game that seems they have something else too them besides their tendencies and ratings *cough* Lebron James *cough*. They have that "Hall of Fame" like cheating to them, like passing through your body or shooting through your hands, or those canimations that pull you into a foul when you didn't even do anything remotely close to what your player just did.

I understand the stars playing like stars, but don't take away my control and freedom just so they can get their numbers in the game.

[BOSsTOwN]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Under

Little Baby
PP
Ray (80. 3pt ?!?!?!?!?!?!?!)
KG

[WyxHarmon]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

John Wall is not over rated. Triple Double in what, his seventh pro game? Yeah, that warrants his rating.


Granger is wayyyyyyy under rated.

[convince]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Underrated
Kobe
D.Howard
Jesus Shuttleworth
K. Perkins
J.J. Hickson
Javel McGee
Dirk
Noah
D. Blair
Josh Smith

Overrated
Deng
Boozer
Vince Carter
R. Lewis
Andre Miller
Bynum
Al Jefferson
Beasley

[Boge]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Kobe underrated? Isn't he a 97 which is tied as the top rated in the game?

How about Paul Milsap? I know the current roster upped him to a 79, but the way he's performed this season...I'm thinking maybe a couple more clicks? 82? He's done much better than Al Jefferson.

[coolcras7]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Under

Little Baby
PP
Ray (80. 3pt ?!?!?!?!?!?!?!)
KG

This Big little baby is a beast in real life in 2k11 he loses the ball every time he get bumped he is a very physical player this need to be fixed as well as the others

[fhhs63]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Underrated
Kobe
D.Howard
Jesus Shuttleworth
K. Perkins
J.J. Hickson
Javel McGee
Dirk
Noah
D. Blair
Josh Smith

Overrated
Deng
Boozer
Vince Carter
R. Lewis
Andre Miller
Bynum
Al Jefferson
Beasley

This, plus or minus a few.

[ggsimmonds]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Overrated
Maybe Chris Bosh. Not drastically, but his medium range shot is higher than most guards. I know the guy has a good J, but better than the elite perimeter players?

[coolcras7]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Overrated
Maybe Chris Bosh. Not drastically, but his medium range shot is higher than most guards. I know the guy has a good J, but better than the elite perimeter players?

Funny every time I simulate a game against the Heat he is always player of the game.

[Shield]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

John Wall is not over rated. Triple Double in what, his seventh pro game? Yeah, that warrants his rating.


Granger is wayyyyyyy under rated.

I agree with Granger being under rated. It seems like whenever i'm looking for a trade the Pacers are always offering him [exaggerating a little] and he scores 30ppg.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Off the top of my head:
Overrated:
Definitely Bosh
Not sure what his overall is but I'd bet Chauncey is a little higher than he should be.
John Wall
Not sure on this one but maybe Wes Johnson

Underrated:
Not sure what his overall is but Michael Beasley's been playing well this year so maybe him
Rondo and Rose might need to be a little higher
Same with Russell Westbrook

[jbels08]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

My choice for under rated is Okur, the man is a beast from the three point range

[BATMON]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

I know Mike Dunleavy was injured for a while but there is no way he is a 68 and Dahntay Jones is a 74.

[icetray23]

Re: Over- /underrated players in the game?

Dirk being rated an 82 stands out the most