Gamerosters.com rosters for 360 here if you want to compair.

[Tateforheisman]

I doubt the community rosters will be out for a week...They are editing EVERYTHING...gonna be a great roster but judging from the thread they got a ways to go.

[SGMRock]

Quote: Originally Posted by jgofett

Why the F is Michigan still rated so high, everyone on the team is in the mid to high 80's. They lost 9 games last season and looked terrible doing it. Where as Michigan State won 9 games and everyone is rated high 70's and low 80's, even some guys in the 50's and 60's, MSU's incoming freshman that were ranked higher then some of Michigans recruits rated in the 60's and 70's when Michigans recruits are in the 80's, their freshman QB Forcier who has never played a down is an 83 where as MSU's QB Maxwell who was the 7th rated QB in high school is a 76. I dont get some of the biased some teams get just based of their name and what they did in the past. Michigan sucks and Michigan fans know it!

Thats pretty silly statement, how can you judge recruits based on last years performance and how can you judge performance of guys that were red shirted last year and were recruited by RR for his offense and not hold overs from Carr's recruits for his offense. You can't.................

[donni101]

Quote: Originally Posted by SGMRock

Thats pretty silly statement, how can you judge recruits based on last years performance and how can you judge performance of guys that were red shirted last year and were recruited by RR for his offense and not hold overs from Carr's recruits for his offense. You can't.................

michigan fans always overrate their guys. this year they should win maybe 7 games. loses msu, osu, psu and i forget the other definite loss. msu is iffy. we'll see how ohio st is this year ditto penn st.

[ActLikeYouCrow]

trindon holliday has been listed at wr at times in the past and apparently now as well, but he's a rb and returner. 88 career carries 4 career catches. i dont buy him playing wr this year.

[jgofett]

Quote: Originally Posted by SGMRock

Thats pretty silly statement, how can you judge recruits based on last years performance and how can you judge performance of guys that were red shirted last year and were recruited by RR for his offense and not hold overs from Carr's recruits for his offense. You can't.................

That itself is silly, if you are not rating players based off their on the field performance, what are you basing their rating off from. I guess because they have the block M on their uni's means they deserve high ratings. Hopefully it is onlt these Gamerosters that have bloated ratings, or that they will be re-evaluated in a future release.

[Sickman]

Thanks for posting those rosters SGMRock, Oregons State seemed a little more accurate. At least these rosters got Lyle Moevao's name correct. Its nice to have more options to choose from with rosters. Still waiting on the Community rosters, they look very promising.

[bb09red]

These are all right but I did notice alot of name mispellings as well and some players not named right.