Ratings Changes Needed Thread

[Spooky]

I didn't see an authoritative thread on a running list of players who need ratings edited for the skill positions. Impact freshman? Top players not getting respect? Some guys rated way too high? List them here. Below is a running list, and the loose recommendation for a change, of guys I saw who probably need a rating change:

*These aren't definitive changes, this is just a list of players that on the surface, appeared to be rated too high or too low for my personal taste. Definitely want to hear some opinions from you all.

QB
Zac Lee, Neb(down, i moved him to 82)
Cody Green, Neb (down, i moved him to 80)
Taylor Martinez, Neb (down, i moved him to 80)
Garrett Gilbert 87, Tex (down)
Landry Jones 90(!), Okla (down)
Dwight Dasher 81, Middle Tenn (up)

RB
Shane Vereen 91, Cal (down)
Daniel Thomas 91, KSU (up)
Derrick Washington 89, Mizzou (up)
Brandon Saine 94(!), OSU (down)
DeMarco Murray 95(!), Okla (down)
Bernard Pierce 88, Temple (up)
Foswhitt Whittaker 88, Texas (down)
Ryan Williams 93, Va Tech (up)

WR
Darvin Adams 86, Auburn (up)
O'Neill Chambers 90(!), BYU (down)
AJ Green 97, Georgia (down)
Greg Salas 87, Hawaii (up)
Terrance Toliver 92, LSU (down)
Michael Floyd 97, ND (down)
Mo Sanu 93(!), Rutgers (down)
Ronald Johnson 94, USC (down)

[DaTwolves21]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

what are you basing these on?

[Spooky]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

what are you basing these on?

Other players rated similarly in the game, stats last year, etc.

[orangeafroman]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

Not a rating, but a position change:

Dee Finely #13 on Florida, switched from FS to OLB...behind Brandon Hicks #40 in the depth chart.

[pezone]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

AJ Green down?? lol

[Spooky]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

AJ Green down?? lol

From a 97, yes. Is he as good as Julio Jones?

I'm not talking huge reduction here, maybe to a 94 or 95. Just my opinion. That's why I'm asking for y'alls too.

[J.C.]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

From a 97, yes. Is he as good as Julio Jones?

I'm not talking huge reduction here, maybe to a 94 or 95. Just my opinion. That's why I'm asking for y'alls too.

Green and Floyd are both better than Jones. 97s are about right for them.

[blakkone]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

did anybody notice some of the individual attributes are not realistic?? look at the default rosters from EA. look who has the best throwing ACCURACY in the game. a freshman?? A freshman QB with a 97 break-tackle?? Im lookin at this like

[12]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

From a 97, yes. Is he as good as Julio Jones?

I'm not talking huge reduction here, maybe to a 94 or 95. Just my opinion. That's why I'm asking for y'alls too.

I'd take Green over Jones every day of the week and twice on Saturday. That's just me though and I have no allegiance to either school.

[12]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

What do you all think about Jake Locker's speed rating?

I know that his acceleration and agility ratings are good, but a speed rating of 72 is kind of laughable to me... You'd be hard pressed to find a player on Washington's roster who is faster than Locker. Not homerism at all; that's a fact. Dude runs between a 4.4 and 4.5 40.

I upped his speed rating to an 88. Maybe I am just not understanding EA's rating system/reasoning for a 72 (C-) rating...

[Spooky]

Re: Ratings Changes Needed Thread

What do you all think about Jake Locker's speed rating?

I know that his acceleration and agility ratings are good, but a speed rating of 72 is kind of laughable to me... You'd be hard pressed to find a player on Washington's roster who is faster than Locker. Not homerism at all; that's a fact. Dude runs between a 4.4 and 4.5 40.

I upped his speed rating to an 88. Maybe I am just not understanding EA's rating system/reasoning for a 72 (C-) rating...

Yeah I thought Locker should be a lot faster in-game.