New QB Rating System

[PrettyT11]

Quote: Originally Posted by kramericaindustries

I was thinking about maybe, for dual threat QB's such as Dobb and Kaepernick, taking the amount of games they've played in and doubling it and adding it to their awareness. Dobbs gets an 84 and Kaepernick gets 82.

Off the top of my head that is pretty close to what I have them at. I left Nesbitt around his default 90 rating going off of what they did last year and how long he has been around.

[kramericaindustries]

AWARENESS/ACCURACY

BALANCED/POCKET PASSERS


M. BARKLEY - 83, 83

KEENUM - 111, 98

J. LOCKER - 91, 82

LUCK - 83, 82

MALLETT - 95, 79

MOORE - 102, 95

DUAL-THREAT/OPTION QB

DOBBS - 94, 78

NESBITT - 82, 67

KAEPERNICK - 92, 85

T. TAYLOR - 82, 82


AWARENESS: PC% + TOTAL TD (Throwing & Running) - INT (-1 for every 2 interceptions). Add class bonus.

ACCURACY: PC% + 1/2 PC% - INT (-1 for every 2 interceptions).

Class Bonuses: (Fr) 1, (RS Fr) 2, (So) 3, (RS So) 4.

AWARENESS FOR QB’S STARTING FOR FIRST TIME (SEASON):

Freshman- 57, (RS) 61

Sophomore- 65, (RS) 69

Junior - 73, (RS) 77

Senior - 81, (RS) 85

+1 for every 3 games played in. +1 for every game started.

AWARENESS, ACCURACY

BRANTLEY - 81, TBD

COLLAROS - 79, TBD

I'm still working out how to subtract from the non-bcs QB's. I just left them where they would stand without the deduction for now.

[SCWinForeverW/OPete]

This looks pretty interesting...

[EHSheadhunter09]

You might want to check for that thread about how AWR is all that matters

[mgoblue678]

Quote: Originally Posted by EHSheadhunter09

You might want to check for that thread about how AWR is all that matters

For simmed games yes, but for played games throwing power and throwing accuracy still matter.

[kramericaindustries]

Yeah I posted about that briefly. Awareness really is all that matters. It sucks because you don't want to have so many Quarterbacks over 81 awareness, but you don't want to have too many (top-tier) Quarterbacks throwing 53% every season.

[SCWinForeverW/OPete]

It doesn't look like anybody's really interested in this, but I am.

Have you figured out how to deduct for non-BCS qbs?

I noticed that Keenum has 111 awareness. And if you move him to 99 awareness and 95 accuracy, he's 99. Kinda seems like a problem.

[kramericaindustries]

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...ve-system.html

redirect here