Would you buy a future NCAA Football title if it DID NOT have roster share?

[CT Pitbull]

H-E double hockey sticks NO...i would never buy this game without roster share i dont have time in my life to edit 123 teams and if im gonna play an ncaa football game i want the correct rosters..i wouldnt be able to go backwards now to the days of non customizable rosters...NO WAY

[edlglide]

Quote: Originally Posted by nhill76

The fact that you called me a dude and told me to grow up shows your age. Just so you know, I'm an adult in my thirties who served in the US Navy for 7 years and currently in college for Sports Management in which I'm taking a Sports Law class in which I had to do research on this matter. I'm not some 15 year old kid talking out of butt. Anyhow, I'm done cause most can't understand the concept of what is taking place and I won't waste anymore time trying to educate you. Just know that in the future, the ability to edit the names will possibly go away.

Well I actually am a licensed attorney, and Keller has almost no shot of winning his lawsuit (at least with regards to eliminating the ability to edit rosters on NCAA).

It's not impossible, but it would require a judge to make some pretty significant leaps and it's unlikely it would stand up on appeal.

[ODogg]

If I can't have the real players and/or names instead of numbers then I don't care how great it is, I ain't buying it...

[ravenmad]

Quote: Originally Posted by nhill76

The fact that you called me a dude and told me to grow up shows your age. Just so you know, I'm an adult in my thirties who served in the US Navy for 7 years and currently in college for Sports Management in which I'm taking a Sports Law class in which I had to do research on this matter. I'm not some 15 year old kid talking out of butt. Anyhow, I'm done cause most can't understand the concept of what is taking place and I won't waste anymore time trying to educate you. Just know that in the future, the ability to edit the names will possibly go away.

What's wrong with calling someone dude? lol. People in their 30's and 40's use the word dude. I guess you never surfed or skateboarded in your life.

And if they take away roster share, fine. But if they take away the ability to edit the real names in, the NCAA franchise might as well just die off. I can deal with having to edit the rosters myself, but I doubt the game would sell enough to make it viable if there were no way to do that. I would totally lose interest if I had to play with randomly generated names or QB#19. I bet EA would fight any lawsuit that would force them to take it away and appeal it into eternity. It's either that or scrap the game altogether. There is no way in hell they take the ability to edit names away. The game itself will go away before that happens. Besides, there really is no case against NCAA because they don't make the roster or use players likenesses in the game at all. They could definitely sue the people making money off of rosters though.

[mtoo22]

I think we would go back to sharing them via memory card or stick if that happened. Not as easy, but still effective.

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S III

[coogrfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by ODogg

If I can't have the real players and/or names instead of numbers then I don't care how great it is, I ain't buying it...

What he said.

[SGMRock]

Shoot I wouldn't even have bought 2013 version if I had read ahead of time that you would not be able to import draft classes to Madden 13. Every year just about I buy bouth of those games and play at least 4 Dynasty seasons so I can export the real named players from NCAA to Madden. This year I get to at least play NCAA 13 with real named players once the community roster for 360 is done. If it had no real names I would not buy NCAA and if they dont put back in the roster export I probably wont by it but every other year or so.

[IHawksFan95]

I probably wouldn't. The only way I could see me buying it is if you had the ability to edit the rosters. If they take that away, NCAA Football would go down the tubes REALLY quick.