Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

[GisherJohn24]

Seriously? A 96 overall?

[nickchowz]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

Says the guy with a Michigan avatar...

He's rated just right in my opinion, you'll see why this year if you didn't notice his athletic ability last year.

[GisherJohn24]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

No, has nothing to do with that at all. It's not just him, it's other players, in the ACC, SEC, you name it. I know he's really good, I admit that, I'm just not justifying that rating. That's a superstar rating to me. A 96 is like a John Elway, a Chad Henne or a Terrell Pryor (yeah, he was good too!) lol

[Barto]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

No, has nothing to do with that at all. It's not just him, it's other players, in the ACC, SEC, you name it. I know he's really good, I admit that, I'm just not justifying that rating. That's a superstar rating to me. A 96 is like a John Elway, a Chad Henne or a Terrell Pryor (yeah, he was good too!) lol

Well, if Michigan OL could learn how to block, then maybe Jadaveon Clowney wouldn't be a 99!

:wink:

[.MgB.]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

He has a point... I get that his speed and such should be high... but his throwing abilities and such should be low enough to bring him back down to earth.

[heitkamp94]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

Seems like the ratings are a bit high compared to the last few versions. It's pretty consistent across the board IMO.

[Darkeus]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

Looks good to me....

And please. Ohio people do not claim LeBron. Don't associate him with real talent.

[BullsFan91]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

Yeah, ratings across the board are too high. There's way too many 90s and 80s players. I wish NCAA would use the same rating scale as Madden.

[GisherJohn24]

Should be a 96 on speed not overall rating. I'm thinking 86

[vikingsfan04]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

I wouldn't worry so much about the overall rating, NCAA's overall rating is inflated. See the fact that once you get a few years into a dynasty, a lot of the top teams will routinely have 3-4 guys in the 96-99 range.

Besides, with Braxton, I think a lot of his actual attributes are pretty spot on. Maybe his passing accuracy is a few points high, but some of his running ratings like elusiveness or juke move could even be higher than they are.

But I get your point...NCAA's overall rating system tosses around high ratings so easily compared to Madden.

[ILikeTheBraves]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

Says the guy with a Michigan avatar...

He's rated just right in my opinion, you'll see why this year if you didn't notice his athletic ability last year.

He can't throw though

[ILikeTheBraves]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

No, has nothing to do with that at all. It's not just him, it's other players, in the ACC, SEC, you name it. I know he's really good, I admit that, I'm just not justifying that rating. That's a superstar rating to me. A 96 is like a John Elway, a Chad Henne or a Terrell Pryor (yeah, he was good too!) lol

Pryor couldn't throw either. Idk how these guys are rated so high as QBs when they are inaccurate

[BullsFan91]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

Should be a 96 on speed not overall rating. I'm thinking 86

Come on man, even as a Wolverine fan I can admit Braxton Miller is way better than an 86.

I'm not one to give out arbitrary random ratings, but a 91 or so seems appropriate for Miller. His speed and other rushing ratings should be really high, but his passing/awareness ratings should leave something to be desired.

For comparison, I think the rating EA gave Devin Gardner (89) is right on point, though his running ratings are too high and his pass accuracy is too low.

[Brutus]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

No, has nothing to do with that at all. It's not just him, it's other players, in the ACC, SEC, you name it. I know he's really good, I admit that, I'm just not justifying that rating. That's a superstar rating to me. A 96 is like a John Elway, a Chad Henne or a Terrell Pryor (yeah, he was good too!) lol

Elway, Henne, and Pryor in the same sentence? Wow

Henne was average at best and Pryor was a thug.

Miller is the real deal. He can throw...very well. His receiving core was not that good last year. This year you will see what he can really do. 96 is pretty close to the mark

[BullsFan91]

Re: Are ratings off on this game? Braxton Miller (OSU) has ratings like Lebron James?

Elway, Henne, and Pryor in the same sentence? Wow

Henne was average at best and Pryor was a thug.

Miller is the real deal. He can throw...very well. His receiving core was not that good last year. This year you will see what he can really do. 96 is pretty close to the mark

Henne, average at best? Dude, WTF?

And then you go on to say that Miller can throw very well?

Miller's only a moderately better passer than Denard Robinson was...