Alright I am new but I am going to have you try something. I have written down every single slider setting named to man. I have tried all levels. I have finally found something that is pretty much flawless. I would even go out on a limb to say it stops 4 verts against the CPU. I am going to list every single slider I use. Please try it out and let me know if it works for you.
I want to be honest. I always play this game on ALL-AMERICAN, but I recently switched it to Varsity and I could not be happier. I am having a harder time against good teams on Varsity than I am on All-American and Heisman. The computer does not try to cheat to win they actually are better at picking you apart if you give them time. This could be all in my head, but I have not thought one time wow I got cheated. Also I never really run 4 verts, but when I do I never get a completion unless I use audibles and hot routes. DBS play AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!
Test it out and let me know how it goes.
(PLEASE TRY EXACTLY HOW I HAVE IT FIRST)
GAMEPLAY OPTIONS
Skill VARSITY (THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT)
Recruiting Difficulty All-American
Injuries ON
Fatigue ON
Quarter Length 8 Minutes
Play Clock ON
Game Speed Normal
PLay Min Thresh 60
Home Field ON
ICE ON
RULES (PASS INTERFERENCE DOESNT WORK PERIOD)
Offsides 90
False Start 95
Holding 45
Facemask 50
OFF INTER 100
DEF INTER 100
KR/
PR Inter 53
Clipping 53
Grounding 53
Roughing Passer 53
Roughing Kick 65
USER/CPU
QB Accuracy 30/5
Pass Blocking 45/75
WR Catch 95/55
Rb Ability 45/70
Run Block 50/55
Pass Cover 50/15
Pass Rush 40/70
Inter 45/35
Rush D 35/100
Tackling 40/20
FG Power 50/55
FG Accur 45/40
Punt Pow 40/55
Punt Acc 55/45
Kickoff 45/45
AUTO/SUBS
OFFENSE
QB OUT/IN 30/31
RB OUT/IN 75/81
WR OUT/IN 65/71
FB/TE OUT/IN 55/61
OL OUT/IN 50/51
DEFENSE
DT OUT/IN 80/91
DE OUT/IN 75/81
LB OUT/IN 50/51
CB OUT/IN 45/46
S OUT/IN 40/41
Coaching Philosophies
Playbook Run Balanced
Run Off/Pass Off 40
Off Play Agg 20
Off Subs 65
Base D 4-3
Run d/Pass D 55
Def PLay AGG 15
D Subs 70
Rec Board off
Scholar Off off
Visit off
Auto Pass off
Auto Sprint off
Auto Strafe off
(PLEASE LET OFF OF SPRINT AND YOUR RUNNING GAME WILL BE AWESOME)
Try these and maybe tweak to your liking.