Should NCAA 2006 just use Madden 2005s gameplay?

[Blaxican8504]

Sorry to be the one disagree, but I dont think this should happen. IMO, NCAA's gameplay is better than Madden's and has been for the last 3 years.

And while I understand that XBOX users have had to deal with the choppiness/slowdown, but even with that, I feel that NCAA had better gameplay than Madden.

1. How many times in Madden have you had a step on the corner and been unable to beat him deep?

2. How many times in Madden have you been able to throw a touch pass that lands between the safety and the corner in a Cover 2?

3. How many times in Madden have you taken control over a corner/safety and end up taking yourself completely out of the play?

4. How many times in Madden have you watched a receiver fail to get seperation against a slower defensive player?

5. How many times in Madden do you feel like you have no control of the players movement?

The flaws in NCAA's gameplay can be fixed with sliders, mainly the CPU offense and dropped passes. There have even been solutions to the slowdown on XBOX.

Now this is just my opinion, but I feel that Madden's gameplay flaws are significantly greater than those of NCAA.

[glucklich]

Quote: Originally Posted by FSU9399

Sorry to be the one disagree, but I dont think this should happen. IMO, NCAA's gameplay is better than Madden's and has been for the last 3 years. And while I understand that XBOX users have had to deal with the choppiness/slowdown, but even with that, I feel that NCAA had better gameplay than Madden. 1. How many times in Madden have you had a step on the corner and been unable to beat him deep? 2. How many times in Madden have you been able to throw a touch pass that lands between the safety and the corner in a Cover 2? 3. How many times in Madden have you taken control over a corner/safety and end up taking yourself completely out of the play? 4. How many times in Madden have you watched a receiver fail to get seperation against a slower defensive player? 5. How many times in Madden do you feel like you have no control of the players movement? The flaws in NCAA's gameplay can be fixed with sliders, mainly the CPU offense and dropped passes. There have even been solutions to the slowdown on XBOX. Now this is just my opinion, but I feel that Madden's gameplay flaws are significantly greater than those of NCAA.

In Madden attributes actually mean something...an apple is an apple and a pear is a pear. When there are speed cheats due to poor AI it becomes reminiscent of 10 Yard Fight (circa 1987).

[TerpsJunkie]

NCAA and Madden need to have different gameplays for me to enjoy both. I would probably only buy NCAA if they both had the same gameplay. Having different ones make each game unique.

[Blaxican8504]

Quote: Originally Posted by glucklich

In Madden attributes actually mean something...an apple is an apple and a pear is a pear. When there are speed cheats due to poor AI it becomes reminiscent of 10 Yard Fight (circa 1987).

That doesnt answer any of the questions that I asked. The things I questioned are things that you are unable to do in Madden, but are able to do in NCAA.

[MrTennessee]

i would like to see a mix of ncaa 2004 and madden 2005's gameplay.

[timmg]

Quote: Originally Posted by glucklich

In Madden attributes actually mean something...an apple is an apple and a pear is a pear. When there are speed cheats due to poor AI it becomes reminiscent of 10 Yard Fight (circa 1987).

I think attributes mean more in NCAA, you see the diffrence between good players and bad players, in Madden Terrence Newman can cover Randy Moss with ease, but I like the gameplay in both games, so hopefully they both keep their own gameplay.

[glucklich]

Quote: Originally Posted by FSU9399

That doesnt answer any of the questions that I asked. The things I questioned are things that you are unable to do in Madden, but are able to do in NCAA.

My point was not to answer any of your questions (which really seemed rhetorical btw) but to point out that there is a greater concern than what you mentioned and also to address your remark about fixing things with sliders which you cant...unless there is a speed cheat slider.

[Pared]

Quote: Originally Posted by MrTennessee

i would like to see a mix of ncaa 2004 and madden 2005's gameplay.

Exactly... just as long as Safeties and Corners aren't glued to WR's on deep routes!

Although... I enjoy NCAA just the way it is now! Love the big hit on NCAA better... it's implemented more realistically, IMO. You can't just blow up everyone....