NCAA best sports game at E3

[hayvis]

IGN did a best of the last games on Xbox a couple of days ago and they awarded NCAA the best sports game. Here's the link. It's only small. http://xbox.ign.com/articles/619/619567p7.html

[Spin]

im glad to hear it was on the xbox.

[RoyalBoyle78]

It's funny how IGN can swing back and forth like they do, They say Ncaa was the best sports game showing at E3 for the xbox, and Madden is the best show at E3 for the PS2. Strange is you ask me.

http://ps2.ign.com/articles/619/619566p5.html

[hayvis]

Maybe the Xbox version of NCAA is just a little more impressive. It seems to be the version that most videos and screenshots are of, and EA definately seems to want to make it clear they made an effort after last years version.

Maybe the PS2 version of Madden just feels a little bit better on PS2 than on Xbox. Anyone played both?

[conboy31]

Quote: Originally Posted by hayvis

Maybe the Xbox version of NCAA is just a little more impressive. It seems to be the version that most videos and screenshots are of, and EA definately seems to want to make it clear they made an effort after last years version.

Maybe. Or maybe they are just playing politics and decided to divy up the award so both games have more advertising credentials... "IGN awarded Madden...IGN awarded NCAA...."

[RoyalBoyle78]

Quote: Originally Posted by hayvis

Maybe the Xbox version of NCAA is just a little more impressive. It seems to be the version that most videos and screenshots are of, and EA definately seems to want to make it clear they made an effort after last years version. Maybe the PS2 version of Madden just feels a little bit better on PS2 than on Xbox. Anyone played both?

Yeah I guess, but the Xbox is maybe more impressive cmpared to other xbox games, cause Ncaa is a port of the PS2 remember that, so I really don't think it's better then the PS2 version or worse.

[Sandman42]

Well, the people that make up the lists are different for each system. So maybe the people that creatted the Xbox list thought NCAA was better and the people that created the PS2 list thought Madden was better.

[hayvis]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheBigPig

Well, the people that make up the lists are different for each system. So maybe the people that creatted the Xbox list thought NCAA was better and the people that created the PS2 list thought Madden was better.

Ah! The answer to the enigma. I'm very glad they like the Xbox version though 'caus that's the one I shall be purchasing.